All the solar in the world won't keep you comfortable.

Written because "insulation" and "airtightness" won't officially be mandated by code until the 2015 IECC is adopted here in Hawaii in March 2019, so we have a good number of houses with no insulation.  Many of them didn't "need" insulation when they were built because houses weren't conditioned, but now that it's easy to throw in mini splits people are discovering that that's no guarantee of success.

-----------------------------------------------------------------

My calls sometimes seem to follow a pattern.  There was this house on the Kohala coast, which had two AC systems already...and the bedroom is still hot, even with both systems running full-tilt.

There was the condo in Kailua-Kona with enormous energy bills despite lots of solar, a decades-old AC system that was putting out nice cool air, ceiling fans in every room...and it's still hot.

There was the house in Waikoloa with THREE split-AC systems, nicely installed, clean and functioning properly...and I got called because it's too hot.

Do you see the pattern?  People get hot, they buy air conditioning, the AC contractor does a nice job, the homeowner gets what they paid for, and it doesn't work.

There's a Better Way

It's not that the AC is "bad" or "broken" or "doesn't work."  All the ones I see actually work pretty well.  They're typically well-installed and of course I usually want to tweak it, but it's not done "wrong."  And it's not the AC contractors' fault either.  There aren't that many of them, they're trying their best to keep up, and they're doing what they're paid to do.

It's that it takes a bit to figure out what's going on and it usually involves looking in attics, doing math, and running some tests.  We need to slow down a bit.

If you go to the doctor and say "my knee hurts," you're not rushed to the hospital for a knee replacement, right?  They run some tests first.

I do the same thing.  Test (don't guess), dig into the house, and THEN make a prescription.  Treat the patient, not the symptoms.

Kohala:

The air leakage is twice as high as Hawaii's Energy Code allows.  The hot attic air gets into the walls and heats them, along with the ceiling, and turns them into radiators.  There is insufficient insulation in the attic, and it's full of holes.  None of these is something that "new AC" can fix.

Kohala, infrared, insulation, AC, air conditioning, Hawaii

The orange on the ceiling shows where insulation is missing. The orange on the walls shows where hot attic air is getting into the walls. These surfaces are hot, hot, hot.

Kailua-Kona:

The condo is on the top floor.  The concrete roof absorbs heat and radiates it at the occupants.  The AC puts out cold air continuously but there's so much radiation the AC is overwhelmed, so the occupants turn it down as much as they can, and the AC and fans run all day.  There is no insulation.  None of these is something "new AC" can fix.

Kona, infrared, insulation, AC, air conditioning, Hawaii

Return (left) and supply (right) temperatures. The 16-degree temperature split is close to a rule-of-thumb ideal.

Waikoloa:

There's no shade, the roof is dark shingles, and there is NO insulation in the attic.  The attic gets hot, heats the ceiling, and as the day progresses the house gets hotter and hotter.  When there are already three (3!) nearly-new split-AC systems...do you think "new AC" is the solution?

Waikoloa, attic, insulation, AC, air conditioning, Hawaii

Look! A blank slate!

 

First Things First

None of these houses has a good barrier between the living space and the hot space.  It can get up to 140 degrees in an attic, hotter than the scalding-hot water in your water heater.  Insulation isn't a magic bullet, but it slows heat transfer - the longer it takes for the ceiling to heat up, the less heat will radiate into the house, and that gives the AC a chance to keep pace.  Then at night, the roof and attic will radiate their heat back into space, cool down, and the cycle starts again in the morning.

If we can slow down how hot your house gets in the first place, we might even get to a point where you don't need AC at all.  Maybe you could stay comfortable with ceiling fans.

There's a reason that "insulation" and "airtightness" are written into Hawaii's Energy Code.  It's because they're the no-energy solution.  They don't make your meter spin, they can save you from trying expensive experiments, they don't need maintenance, and they work all the time.

AC only works some of the time, if it works at all.  But it works better if it comes after insulation.

There's a reason I do a lot of insulation and airtightness - it always works.  I like it when things work all the time.

Not just some of the time.

 

Previous Blogs on Similar Topics:

The Trouble With Holes

Managing Mold and Humidity

Views: 114

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Blake Reid on November 8, 2018 at 2:29pm

Thank you Franco!  That gives me a topic for another blog: "All the Things You Have To Watch To Get Your AC To Work That You Don't Have To Worry About With Insulation."  Title needs work tho LOL.

Comment by Franco Oyuela on November 6, 2018 at 1:35pm

Reasons why your air conditioner isn’t working as well as it could be.

Dirty condenser coils.
Coolant problems
Clogged air filter
A defective thermostat
A faulty compressor
Very high temperatures
An undersized (or oversized) air conditioner

Latest Activity

Diane Chojnowski added a discussion to the group News & Announcements
Thumbnail

Volunteer for HPC19

Volunteer & Receive FREE Registration to HPC19HPC is looking for volunteers for the national…See More
11 minutes ago
Don Fugler replied to Don Fugler's discussion Depressurization/make-up air issues in the group Kitchen Ventilation
"I saw an interesting article on cleaning make-up air which referenced the hardware found in…"
12 minutes ago
Profile IconSamantha Totoni, Thomas Crown, Christopher Ludy and 3 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
10 hours ago
KRicket Smith-Gary replied to Tom Smith's discussion Are Energy Efficient Windows worth the investment?
"There is more to windows than just their individual performance- they are usually the least…"
14 hours ago
Emily Ambrose's blog post was featured

Focused Strategy: The Rising Tide Effect of Precision Marketing

Among the many challenges we face as digital marketers, some of the strongest and most consistent…See More
yesterday
Franco Oyuela replied to Steve Nations's discussion high rise humidity
"Why Is My House So Humid? imply put, high humidity in a home occurs when moisture comes into a home…"
yesterday
Franco Oyuela commented on John White's blog post HVAC Spring Maintenance Checklist
"Spring HVAC Maintenance Checklist. Inspect the indoor coil for cleanliness and clean if…"
yesterday
Profile IconChristine Brill and JES joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Tuesday

© 2019   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service