How Many Hours-of-Safety Do Our Homes Have in Extreme Weather?

How many people in your community are at risk during extreme weather events? The heat waves wracking the nation right now can cause heat exhaustion, heatstroke, dehydration, and even death. Last year over 90 people died in Quebec (over 50 in Montreal) due t.... And during Chicago’s famous 1995 heat wave over 700 people died. When the power goes out—which often happens with extreme temperatures—the problem becomes dramatically larger. With fans, air conditioners, and refrigerators unable to provide any relief, the question is clear: how long can a home maintain the last comfortable temperature it had before conditions inside the home match the extreme conditions outside the home? This is what we’re calling hours-of-safety, which can determine the difference between safety and danger.

Critical Hours to Understand

The difference between 20 hours of safe and comfortable in-home temperatures and only 5 hours could be the difference between life and death for vulnerable populations. It makes the difference between staving off heatstroke until the power is returned, allowing time for family or neighbors to arrive and provide support, or buying time to evacuate. We need to understand our homes in terms of the hours-of-safety they can provide when the power goes out to reduce the amount of time people are exposed to extremely hot or cold temperatures.

While there has been considerable work to define metrics for the resilience of the electricity grid, there has been little work done on how long buildings are able to maintain healthy temperature levels. Homes vary widely in their ability to maintain comfort during these events, and we need to start making our homes better prepared. Fortunately, making homes more efficient and safer can be accomplished while providing other benefits such as lower energy bills.

The Growth of Extreme Weather Events

Today we’re seeing extreme temperatures happening more frequently across the country, and the magnitude and frequency of extreme weather events will only grow over time. The National Resource Defense Council (NRDC) projects that by 2100 the United States will experience almost 30,000 heat-related deaths every year if current levels of carbon dioxide emissions persist.

This past weekend, 50,000 New York city customers lost power, and 6,000 still did not have power more than 24 hours later. In 2016, outages tended to average around four hours during major events, and in some states between 8 and 20 hours—and that’s the average, meaning some events last longer. Between January and June 2019, over 2.9 million customers were out of power for a total of 684 hours as a result of outages caused by severe weather.

Extreme temperatures are particularly a problem for lower-income housing, vulnerable populations, and people living in social isolation. This is exacerbated by the fact that low-income housing is often poorly insulated and very drafty.

Hours-of-safety is just as relevant during cold weather events as during heat waves: when it’s hot outside leaky and poorly insulated homes can’t keep out the heat; when it’s cold outside, they can’t keep out the cold. This past winter many regions were struggling with polar vortex after polar vortex that hammered communities with extreme cold conditions. As temperatures plunged in the Midwest this past winter up to negative 31 degrees, at least 21 people died and many more were affected by frostbite and hypothermia. Thus, hours of safety is a year-round problem.

Smart Building Strategies Can Make a Difference

City governments and other policymakers should consider how to support better community resilience and safety by addressing this need. Fortunately, the building industry can play a role in equipping our cities to be more resilient against extreme heat and cold through a variety of strategies. The Resilient Design Institute defines passive survivability as “a building’s ability to maintain livable conditions when sources such as electricity, water, or heating fuel are cut off.” Considering hours-of-safety can help improve the passive survivability of a building and can help save lives. The main thing that determines how many hours-of-safety a home has in extreme weather power outages comes down to two things: how well insulated the home is and how much air leakage the home has between the inside and the outside.

Passive design strategies such as a tighter envelope and more insulation can also help make buildings more efficient and resilient in both cold and hot temperatures. Implementing features such as cool roofs and thicker walls can contribute to buildings that stay comfortable for longer in the event of a power outage. A study from Passive House Institute US found that lower window-to-wall ratios and natural ventilation are helpful in maintaining favorable conditions during summer outages. In warm climates, simple changes such as adding white paint could lower roof temperatures by as much as 30°C or 86°F and indoor temperatures by 3.6°F to 9°F. Having thick walls can help buildings maintain moderate indoor temperatures. For example, residents of Brooklyn living in a house with highly insulated walls maintained an indoor temperature of around 60°F–72°F although outside temperatures dropped to almost 0°F in the 2014 Polar Vortex.

A more efficient building envelope can be combined with other resilient design strategies such as islandable solar PV systems and battery storage that can keep systems going during power outages even at times when the sun isn’t shining.

These components provide a significant added value during extreme weather events that will only become more common over the next century. Society needs a way to consider that value alongside energy cost savings. This will help us understand if our buildings are prepared for the extreme weather events that are unfortunately becoming more frequent. Understanding the hours-of-safety that our homes provide can give us piece of mind or at least clear parameters on how we need to respond to emergencies.

Views: 61

Tags: change, climate, efficiency, extreme, insulation, temperatures


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Dennis Heidner on August 8, 2019 at 7:56pm

Good post for thermal safety.

One area missed is beyond just the temperature ranges -- is how the house responds to moisture.  If the heating / cooling system is no longer available is the house able to maintain the relative humidity in a range that still prevents mold growth.. can the house dry out?   A failed HVAC system in the SouthEast  because of extreme events - may not cause health problems because of the heat - but the humidity if not lowered may result in mold growth that condemns the house.

Passive houses with out adequate ventilation can AND DO result in poor indoor air quality.  Opening a window to maintain that fresh air when you are experience a polar vortex --- well it pretty much defeats the purpose of beating the 0.6ACH50 rule.


Air Sealing Manufactured Home

Started by John Lile in General Forum. Last reply by Darin Pleines 22 hours ago. 10 Replies

Solar ROI Calculator

Started by Kyle Baker in General Forum yesterday. 0 Replies

Does Radiant Barrier Still Work 10 Years Later?

Started by Green Energy of San Antonio in General Forum. Last reply by Sean Wiens on Friday. 2 Replies

Best Exhaust Fans - your opinion?

Started by Eric Miller in General Forum. Last reply by Russell Pope on Thursday. 3 Replies

October 2 is Energy Efficiency Day

Started by Diane Chojnowski in General Forum on Thursday. 0 Replies

ERV recommendations

Started by David Wentling in General Forum. Last reply by Luke Langhals Sep 11. 13 Replies

Baffles without soffit vents?

Started by Haley Keegan in Best Practices. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus Sep 9. 14 Replies

Off-Grid Applications?

Started by Kyle Baker in General Forum. Last reply by Paul Scheckel Sep 5. 2 Replies

Latest Activity

Profile IconChase Roberts, Omni Real Estate and Kevin M Dugan joined Home Energy Pros Forum
2 hours ago
Darin Pleines replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"In illinois WAP program we seal the belly material and lightly dense pack the cavity with loose…"
22 hours ago
Brian Robinson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"The first place to look when working on trailers / manufactured home is the…"
tedkidd replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Spray foam the road barrier."
Tom Wilson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"The good news is the linoleum IS the air/vapor barrier and unless it is put under 50 Pa negative…"
Kyle Baker posted a discussion

Solar ROI Calculator

How do you know when you get a payback on installing a solar system? What ROI have you received…See More
Robin Henry replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Sorry if I'm preaching to the choir but careful sealing up mobiles too tightly as they are…"
Tom Wilson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Typo corrections: This is the classic problem folks have been wrestling with forever with…"
Ed Minch replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Many of the WAP programs have written extensively on sealing of these guys.  West Virginia in…"
Tom Wilson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"This is the classic problem folks have been wrestling with forever with manufactured…"
Rich Mialki Jr replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Does this really matter much?  Think of what the blower door is doing as opposed to natural…"
Emily Ambrose's blog post was featured

© 2019   Created by Building Performance Association   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service