When I was a Peace Corps Volunteer, I watched as a line of telephone poles inched its way over the 60 kilometers to my site.  They didn't get all the way there, because they were so slow that during the project, these newfangled "cell phones" showed up.  Everyone decided to get cell phones instead of landlines, so they quit putting in poles.

This kind of leapfrogging can be an advantage - slow down, learn what other people are doing, and then do what's right for you.  It can be very efficient!

"Building airtightness" has been studied since the '80s, so it's not new.  But it is to Hawaii, and Hawaii found a great sweet spot.

A Quick Note on "Code"

We have plumbing codes because people were getting sick, electrical codes because buildings were catching fire, structural codes because buildings were falling down...and now energy codes because energy is expensive, is becoming more so, and its production can harm the climate.  The Energy Code was created partly as a reaction to peoples' discomfort, and in Hawaii, it's designed to keep houses cooler by encouraging better building design.  If a house is hot, homeowners typically think "I need air conditioning," but that doesn't always work and it uses energy, which costs a lot.  The first Energy Code came out in 2000, so it's not new either.

A house that "meets Code" passes minimum standards.  It could be built better than Code, right?  That's all the Energy Code wants, for houses to be better than "barely OK."

How Do You Do a Blower Door Test?

A home's level of airtightness can be calculated pretty easily.  A big fan is installed in a door, and as it moves air out of the building, the air is measured with a gauge.  When you put that together with the volume of the building, you get a leakage rate.

blower door hawaii

The round thing is the fan. The red thing is a shroud, installed on an expandable frame

so it fits in almost any door. The small rectangular thing with buttons is the gauge.

Let's say you have a 2000 square foot house with eight-foot ceilings.  Its volume is 2000 x 8 = 16,000 cubic feet.  If I set a blower door up in your house and measure an airflow of 1000 cubic feet per minute while the fan's running, we put them together this way:

ACH50 calculation

The "60" is in there to convert minutes to hours, and the "3.75" is a measure of the house's leakage.  It's in "air changes per hour at a pressure difference of 50 Pascals" but that's a mouthful so we just say "ACH50."  This house has a leakage rate of 3.75 ACH50.

Hawaii's maximum allowed leakage rate is 5 ACH50, so this house would pass.  It's very simple.  Smaller numbers are better.  A bigger number indicates a leaky house, which is bad for energy bills.  Leakier houses also tend to be more uncomfortable, which is probably why those clients call me.  I routinely measure leakage rates of about 10 ACH50, twice what the Code allows.

But It's Hawaii.  Why Do We Need It?

I hear these comments all the time:

  • "We don't need air conditioning in Hawaii."
  • "Open the windows."
  • "Tighter houses will get moldy."
  • "It costs too much."

Hawaii has a lot of climate zones; some people don't need air conditioning, but some people do, especially with how hot our summers are getting.  And our kupuna and keiki can be especially affected by the heat.

But tightening houses isn't just about "keeping the cool in."  A bigger reason it's important is that it helps keep the heat OUT.  (We've been here before, with the ceiling-and-walls-that-act-like-radiators)  If a house is kept cooler in the first place, then it's less likely to need A/C, and we can have the houses that Hawaii's supposed to be able to have.  One reason people "need A/C" is that the houses are built to an older standard, and they get hotter faster.  A newer house might still get hot, but slower.  It might get hot so slowly that ceiling fans, on their own, could keep you cool.

infrared, IR, AC, heat, blower door, airtightness

Big holes are letting 140-degree attic air into this wall. The air heats the drywall and turns it into a big radiator. If there were no holes, the wall would be cooler and so would you.

Hawaii's airtightness requirement is also pretty appropriately-sized.  It's designed to go after the big, wasteful holes that hurt and don't help.  Builders don't have to spend a lot of time chasing down tiny cracks because small holes only leak a small amount of air.  Big holes leak a lot, are easy to find, and cheap to fix.

The holes also don't help.  They don't encourage ventilation because they're not where you want them.  They're in weird places like "under your house" and "in your attic."  Who wants ventilation air from those places?  Gross.  If you want ventilation, that's what windows and fans are for.  Those are holes you get to choose to use.

Randomly-located holes installed during the construction process typically allow bad air to get to places you don't want it.  Closing those holes makes houses better, not worse.

The Sweet Spot

I think Hawaii decided on a perfect airtightness target.

At one time, I was doing blower door tests on houses that had to meet 7 ACH50.  That bar is so low you could stumble right over it.  There wasn't much of a point, and we learned that.

Many jurisdictions require 3 ACH50, tighter than Hawaii specifies.  That's a bit more challenging of a target, and is useful because many of those houses need both air conditioning AND heating.  There are more opportunities to save energy.

climate zone map ACH50 blower door airtightness

Climate zone map of the US mainland. The red and pink areas generally require 5 ACH50,

same as Hawaii.  Everywhere else is in a zone where 3 ACH50 is a target.

Hawaii's 5 ACH50 is right in the middle.  Not hard to achieve, not too stringent.  Any builder should be able to meet it, and if they don't, it's good that they're being checked, isn't it?

I do think it's weird that 5 ACH50 is about half of what I often measure on Hawaii houses.  Is it a sign?  Or a statement?  I don't know.

I do know that if those houses had their air leakage cut in half, the A/C would work a whole lot better all of a sudden.

blower door airtightness Hawaii air leakage

A 0-10 scale from a recent report to a homeowner. Higher scores are not better.

If you need a blower door test, get in touch.  I do them, but I don't believe in testing-for-the-sake-of-testing.  When I do one, I like to use it as a teaching tool.

The goal isn't to do tests.  It's to seal holes and make buildings better, and those are things I love to do.

Originally posted here: https://terrawatthome.com/blog/blower-door-testing-hawaii

Previous Blogs on Similar Topics:

Your AC Doesn't Work and Here's Why

The Trouble With Holes

What You Can Do About Vog

Views: 87

Tags: ACH50, airtightness, blower, door, hawaii


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Blake Reid on August 22, 2019 at 4:45pm

thank you Jeff & Ed!

Comment by Jeff Luoma on August 22, 2019 at 11:08am

I love how Blake describes complex concepts.

Comment by Ed Minch on August 15, 2019 at 11:13am

Glad to see they went with 5 ACH50.  This is very easy to achieve in even small houses and with your minimal DD in both heating and cooling seasons, the need for very low numbers is not there.  


Thoughts on EVs? Love em or hate em?

Started by Kyle Baker in General Forum. Last reply by David Butler 13 hours ago. 3 Replies

Capillary break retrofit

Started by Paul Raymer in Best Practices. Last reply by Paul Raymer on Thursday. 3 Replies

Help with OpenStudio/EnergyPlus

Started by Kerry Haglund in General Forum. Last reply by Kerry Haglund on Thursday. 1 Reply

Insulating Chilled/Cold Water Lines

Started by Sean Wiens in HVAC. Last reply by Sean Wiens Jan 20. 10 Replies

What's the Most Profitable HVAC Job for Your Company?

Started by Wayne Melancon in HVAC. Last reply by bebelyn accessdoors Jan 16. 5 Replies

Looking for a Rater in Sacramento Area

Started by Brian A McFadden in BPI. Last reply by Building Performance Institute Jan 14. 1 Reply

Hydronic System Critique

Started by Sean Wiens in HVAC. Last reply by Sean Wiens Jan 14. 8 Replies

Latest Activity

Building Performance Journal posted a blog post

Now Accepting Nominations for the Linda Wigington Leadership Award

The Building Performance Association is now accepting nominations for the Linda Wigington…See More
7 hours ago
Anna Stern liked Chris Laumer-Giddens's blog post Near Perfect Air Tightness Measured in Contemporary Home
11 hours ago
David Butler replied to Kyle Baker's discussion Thoughts on EVs? Love em or hate em?
"@Kyle, I spotted an error in the article. You wrote: > Washington DC: <$0.10 per kWh…"
13 hours ago
Sean Wiens replied to Kyle Baker's discussion Thoughts on EVs? Love em or hate em?
"If you are concerned about environmental footprint, then they make no sense in the USA at all…"
15 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Diane Chojnowski's group News & Announcements
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Diane Chojnowski's discussion Nominations open for Linda Wigington Leadership Award
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Diane Chojnowski's discussion Volunteer for HPC19
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Diane Chojnowski's discussion Building Performance Association December Newsletter
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Diane Chojnowski's discussion BPI Winter 2019 Performance Matters Newsletter
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Wayne Melancon's discussion What's the Most Profitable HVAC Job for Your Company?
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Building Performance Journal's blog post Dust-Control Strategies for Energy Upgrades
16 hours ago
Building Performance Institute liked Macie Melendez's blog post Re-introducing Myself as the Building Performance Journal’s Managing Editor
16 hours ago

© 2020   Created by Building Performance Association   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service