John S. Rodenhizer
  • South Hamilton, MA
  • United States
Share on Facebook Share
  • Blogs
  • Discussions (4)
  • Events
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Photo Albums
  • Videos

John S. Rodenhizer's Discussions

Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Dennis Heidner May 22. 19 Replies

I recently inspected a house that I am rating and discovered the HVAC contractor used Big 8 bubble wrap on the metal main duct in a vented attic in Climate zone 5. I spoke to the contractor about…Continue

 

John S. Rodenhizer's Page

Latest Activity

John S. Rodenhizer replied to David Wentling's discussion ERV recommendations
"As a Rater and PH guy I have seen a number of units. You do get what you pay for. I also commission for Zehnder, about 180+ to date. Having the ability to dial  in every room to meet a design spec is really special. 2 ECM fans and there…"
Sep 5
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Pests are also a really good reason to seal duct work with either the approved mastic OR aluminum duct tape... not the sticky "un-Duct" tape that DIYers use... "un-Duct" can be tasty for some critters..."
May 22
Mark Furst replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Hmm, good point. I didn't notice any droppings but it could be. I'll check my other pics."
May 22
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"If you look closely ... can you see rat or mice teeth marks on foil?   Some of the modern materials are gourmet meals for rodents.   E.g.  they really enjoy a snack on some PEX  or the insulation from some automobile…"
May 22
Mark Furst replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"On a tangentially related topic: I saw this today in an old attic installed AC system. Ducts made from only fiber-board, coming apart at the corners."
May 22
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"I believe one of the issues is how does one defend themselves against an HVAC contractor that insists it is okay.   And the answer to that would have to be pull articles from ACCA or AHRI which say that reflective bubble wrap is worthless…"
May 20
Gabriel Perez replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"I’ll give you an a for effort but even in the best cases bubble wrap ( unless it comes with a certificate of testing and depending on what lab was used) means nothing. If you can get a engineer’s stamp with signature maybe that might…"
May 20
Paul Herron replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"I think Ed and his video hit on an important point -- these radiant barriers are primarily addressing radiant energy.  They aren't doing much to address conduction losses and, if not installed properly, will not address convection…"
May 20
John S. Rodenhizer replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Agreed, But this guy fought me all the way. I have completed the rating and the HVAC contractor added R-8 on Top of the bubble wrap. We had to hit a HERS of 55 or below and when I gave the duct insulation R-1.1 it increased the HERS score to 57. the…"
May 20
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Links for Build America and Building Science…"
May 20
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Correct,   but when testing has been done on sealing ducts with wraps... (See the BTO and Build America website for reports... plenty of research done by ASHRAE and universities also) the seals are never really tight enough to prevent the…"
May 20
David Butler replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"@Dennis, without defending Big-8, I would point out that condensation (on duct surface) is a function of how well the vapor barrier (the outer layer) is sealed. This issue is exactly the same with conventional foil-faced fiberglass duct wrap. It,…"
May 20
Caleb Y Simon replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"I concur with your IMC interpretation. I have used this before with code officials and they have had to agree. Look forward to hearing what the "official" response is from RESNET."
May 20
Ed Fritz replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"As a radiant barrier manufacturer I've been fighting this bad information for years. I've run into this claim for installing radiant barrier in attics many times.  Which is similar the claims made for wrapping ducts.  This is a…"
May 20
Dennis Heidner replied to John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
"Read the manufacturers claims and installation steps closely  The foil needs a dead space  "To achieve a thermal resistance of R-8, 2-inch-wide spacer strips of rFOIL™ reflective foil insulation arewrapped around the duct…"
May 19
Robert Zockoff liked John S. Rodenhizer's discussion Using radiant barriers as duct insulation, Aka "Bubble wrap" What value do you assign for R-value?
May 16

Profile Information

Company
JSR Adaptive Energy Solutions LLC
Role in Home Performance Marketplace
Building energy modeler, Contractor: general (new/remodel), Energy auditor / assessor / analyst
Professional Certification
HERS Rater, Other
Professional Interests
CPHC, PHIUS Rater, CPHB,and PH verifier
Website URL
http://jsradaptivenergy.com
LinkedIn Profile
John S Rodenhizer

Comment Wall (1 comment)

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

At 8:16am on October 3, 2017, Diane Chojnowski said…

Hi John,

Welcome to Home Energy Pros Forum. Feel free to join the conversation in the Forum and Groups. And share your energy efficiency photos, videos and upcoming events. If you're blogging about home performance, this is the place for you!

Don't forget to upload your profile photo.

Thanks!
Diane, HEP Moderator

 
 
 

Latest Activity

Profile IconChris Crawford, Jerry Herron, Baker Electric Home Energy and 1 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
1 hour ago
Dennis Heidner replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Yup,  I'm not sure you want to even try tightening up a modular home built before…"
12 hours ago
Dennis Heidner replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"You made some very important observations. It's really important to think about how tight you…"
12 hours ago
Tom Wilson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Unless the home is on a permanent block or concrete foundation, attempting this is a lost cause.…"
12 hours ago
Tom Wilson replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Actually, it was only in 1976 that any standards at all were applied to mobile homes:  U.S.…"
12 hours ago
Dennis Heidner replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"You didn't mention anything about the age of these homes.  Early mobile/modular homes…"
12 hours ago
David Butler replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Notwithstanding the typical low budget for these homes, it seems like encapsulating the crawl might…"
13 hours ago
Chris Clay replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Thanks Ed, Yes the duct system is outdoors. It came from the factory that way. After working on…"
16 hours ago
Ed Minch replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Chris I agree, and then notice that puts the duct system outside of the house.  So the duct…"
17 hours ago
Home Energy Magazine posted an event
Thumbnail

Getting to Zero Forum: OCTOBER 9-11, 2019 OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA at Oakland, California

October 9, 2019 at 6pm to October 11, 2019 at 7pm
The Getting to Zero Forum is a solutions-based event Dedicated to zero energy and zero carbon…See More
20 hours ago
Chris Clay replied to John Lile's discussion Air Sealing Manufactured Home
"Hi John, The primary air barrier of all mobile home is the subfloor and that is what should be air…"
21 hours ago

© 2019   Created by Building Performance Association   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service