Looking to Make Your Home More Comfortable and Healthy? Building Scientists Say ‘Air Seal First. See Your House as a System & Look Up in the Attic.’

Caption:  Average monthly energy bills are $14 at the Villas at Rocketts Landing,  DOE's  2017, Housing Innovation Award Winner, thanks to a combination of solar power, tight construction, air sealing and innovation HVAC system placement and insulation. 

Building scientists are a data-driven skeptical bunch. When asked what we homeowners can do to reduce bills and increase comfort, one responded, “there are no silver bullets and no unicorns here.”  Fair enough, but after talking to some very independent-minded home performance problem solvers and insulation and HVAC specialists, there was a clear consensus:  start by air sealing - find air leaks and fix them - and only hire those who see your home as a system.

“In the past HVAC techs would show up at the door, knock and go straight to the equipment.  That should never be the first stop,” says Stephen Rardon, an HVAC contractor, owner of Rardon Home Performance.  “The HVAC system heats or cools within an envelope, Rardon continued. “When I talk to my heros in the industry, they almost always say that when you’re looking to boost comfort, first focus on control.  If you have control of your environment you’ll be able to keep it comfortable,”  he added.

“Building science is really about focusing on the big picture,” explains Allison Bailes PhD in physics, co-founder of Energy Vanguard and a pro’s pro in building science.  As he explained in a widely shared 2017 blog post, “... we need to know which direction heat, air, and moisture are likely to flow. In analyzing failures, we can rely on that direction of flow to help us understand what happened.”  

Bailes argues for an energy audit, the use of a equipment like blower door test, “to see how leaky a house is and pinpoint the problems.”  Similarly, Nate Adams, founder of Energy Smart Home Performance and author of The Home Comfort Book, argues that contractors and HVAC specialists can’t remedy what they can’t measure and encourages homeowners to hire a contractor to do an energy audit and blower door test.

Moreover, testing at home is not an end in  itself but a mechanism to improve the lived experience. “The reason to do a project is to make your home more comfortable and healthy. A common question we ask in our world is ‘What's the payback on granite countertops?’  Do the blower door test and commit to a project to make your home better,” Energy Smart Home Performance’s Adams added.

And what do building scientists tend to find, what do those tests generally find, and how do the pros look to get control of the envelope?

Start with Air Sealing

“Nine times out of ten, the items on the top of the list are related to air sealing.  As we say - seal tight, ventilate right,” Matt Patmon, BPI-certified, owner of Triangle Radiant Barrier in North Carolina agreed.  “Air sealing doesn’t cost a lot of money and you get an outstanding result. It is simply always most affordable.”

Adams too agreed, “Here are my top five: air seal, air seal, air seal, insulate, and install the right HVAC system.”

And where to start fixing air leaks?

“The attic and crawl spaces.  Most attics have pulldown stairs. The attic hatch is always an easy go-to air sealing opportunity.  I’m extremely surprised when I see an attic hatch that isn’t leaking, ” Rardon of Rardon Home Performance shared.

Look Up in the Attic

“Look up in the attic, that’s where you have the most extreme temperatures - if it’s a 90 degree day in the summer,  up in the attic it’ll be 120-130 degrees,” says Patmon of Triangle Radiant Barrier,  ‘In the attic it is all about air sealing -  insulation doesn’t block air and getting rid of air leaks around the penetrations between the drywall and attic, the cut-ins for the lighting and most importantly, the attic hatch. The attic hatch is inevitably the biggest source of air leakage.”

“The traditional solution for attic hatch air sealing had been foam board and weatherstripping,” explains Tom Sprouse, co-founder of Creative Conservation,  a high performance  insulation company located in Richmond VA. He prefers a new, locally designed and manufactured attic hatch seal, Attic Zipper, which is more pliable, resilient and easier to install in existing homes or new builds than traditional solutions.  

While the building scientists caution against looking for silver bullet solutions, those who find new ways to solve chronic high-frequency problems like attic air sealing are compelled to share what they learned.  Jay Epstein,  the 2017 recipient  of the Department of Energy’s Housing Innovation Award for Zero Energy   Ready Home (EZEH), elected to use Attic Zipper attic hatch products at Rocketts Landing, a first-of-its-kind affordable net zero solar homes in  Richmond, Virginia.  “We use what's called an attic zipper, which is a sensational piece that actually works well, where you can actually Velcro R-50, which is what we have in our attics above it, and it's just a great, simple piece of technology,” he explained in his 2017   DOE Housing Innovation Award webinar.

Focus on the Crawl Spaces Openings (Especially Drop Down Stairs) 

At Rocketts Landing, Attic Zipper achieved a  1.23 ACH and 486 CFM @ 50P.  Or to put it in more general terms, “This product really works,” Epstein said.  “Stopping air leakage in the attic and conditioned crawl space is an important factor in designing a net zero home. The Attic Zipper for attic and conditioned crawl access stops the normal air leakage in conditioned crawl access doors and attic access opening.  This product really works.”   

And increasingly, insulation, HVAC contractors  and home performance experts say homeowners are being more proactive around taking steps.

Caption:  Attic Hatch Covers like this 'Attic Zipper' being installed in Richmond Va, combat air leaks and add much needed insulation to attic stair openings. Experts suggest focusing on air sealing when homeowners look to boost comfort, reduce HVAC system fatigue and  drive down heating bills.

Views: 773

Tags: 101, Building, DOE, HVAC, Landing, Rocketts, Science, air, alternative, attic, More…awards, build, building, energy, hatch, health, home, innovation, insulation, new, retrofit, science, sealing, zipper


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Michael Schettine on March 8, 2018 at 12:45pm


Answer to new construction is above...

Existing structures are a whole different animal however its bad judgment keep pushing out poor performance (new) homes expecting a new result...it take a slight different approach to what most building science people have in their toolbox about where the intrusion is really coming from.         

Comment by William Collins on March 8, 2018 at 12:27pm

Thanks Ed

Comment by Ed Minch on March 8, 2018 at 12:03pm


As an industry we have been sealing existing houses and ducts using diagnostic equipment for guidance for almost 40 years now. We had organized existing home sealing a couple of years before we had organized new home sealing.


Comment by William Collins on March 8, 2018 at 11:29am


Question? How do we deal with all of the existing housing stock which needs air sealing in their attics and on the ducts? 



Comment by Michael Schettine on March 8, 2018 at 10:23am

Proper education on air-sealing needs to be done during the framing phase...not "post frame" with caulks and a bootstrap approach that won't last. Sealing during framing creates a more durable and less cost solution to performance.  

Comment by William Collins on March 8, 2018 at 10:13am


Great article. We need more info out there about air sealing. 


Latest Activity

Sean Lintow Sr replied to David Meiland's discussion Air gap above floor insulation--how big is the impact?
"Yes & no - newer codes added in "Exception: As an alternative, the floor framing-cavity…"
3 hours ago
Dan Phillips replied to tedkidd's discussion It is time for government programs to end. They become monopolies that block market solutions.
"Not all states used deemed savings or modeled savings.  Don't throw the baby out with the…"
5 hours ago
Dan Phillips replied to David Meiland's discussion Air gap above floor insulation--how big is the impact?
"I wonder if you could do an experiment.  Leave a section of the floor insulation as is. …"
5 hours ago
Dennis Heidner replied to Tim Kendzia's discussion Cooling effect from solar panels
"I had missed your query originally made a couple of years ago.   Yes it does make a…"
15 hours ago
Dannie Jackson replied to Tom Smith's discussion Are Energy Efficient Windows worth the investment?
"If you look at the R factor of the window and compare it to old school single pain glass windows…"
16 hours ago
Dannie Jackson replied to tedkidd's discussion It is time for government programs to end. They become monopolies that block market solutions.
"Something that bothers me which is very similar to the concerns about agencies and programs…"
16 hours ago
Dannie Jackson replied to Tim Kendzia's discussion Cooling effect from solar panels
"I would assume two things about this idea, first of all you would definitely shade the roof and…"
16 hours ago
Charles Buell replied to David Meiland's discussion Air gap above floor insulation--how big is the impact?
"You want to install enough insulation that the room temp line is within the insulation---not…"
20 hours ago

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service