Efficient + Disaster Resilient = Sustainable

Picture a so-called “green” building in a floodplain.  Now picture a storm-hardened home guzzling gas like there is no tomorrow.

For me, neither of these conjures up an image of true sustainability.

By virtue of being built unconsciously (or defiantly) in harm’s way, a building is not durable and thus not (in my book) sustainable.  Similarly, a disaster-resilient building belching out greenhouse gases that any scientist worth their salt will tell you is contributing to present and future natural hazards is not sustainable.

Substantial, but largely unconnected efforts have been made for decades on energy-efficiency (and self-generation) and disaster resilience.  We have developed an arsenal of methods for making buildings energy efficient and otherwise environmentally responsive.  And we have an equally large arsenal for making them disaster resilient.
Both can be done in tandem, but rarely are, thanks to society’s deeply ingrained ability to stove-pipe subjects that they deem unrelated.

Recognition of this the need for an integrated approach has been coming from an unexpected quarter: the insurance industry.  Zurich, for example, has noted that “Unfortunately, disaster resilience is not generally associated with being green, and has not been integrated to any great extent in the sustainability dialogue. ... Further research on the links between disaster resilience, energy savings and off-grid power systems might also help solve this conundrum…”  Other insurers have given premium credits for buildings that have self-generation (recognizing that so-called 'business-interruption' losses will be lower following grid outages).

This thinking can be applied at a neighborhood and regional level as well.  Tokio Marine insurance (one of the largest in Japan) has for more than a decade run a large-scale program to reforest mangrove forests.  They’re replanted almost 20,000 acres of mangroves in Indonesia, Fiji, Thailand, Philippines, Myanmar, Vietnam, and India  and claim that this has simultaneously offset their own corporate carbon footprint while also lessening the impacts of storm surge on coastal real estate.

Examples of how energy-efficiency can support the goals of disaster resilience--and visa versa--abound.

Efficient envelopes make homes more habitable when the HVAC goes down during power outages, and are less susceptible to ice dam damage.  Distributed power systems can keep the lights on when the broader grid is down. LED exit signs are more visible through smoke.  Closed-cell foam insulation can withstand water and flood damage far better than fiber-based insulation materials. Occupants of efficient buildings are less vulnerable to health problems during heatwaves.

While in Australia this month I met with building officials providing advice during the reconstruction effort following massive wildfires in 2009.  They have developed a five-step level rating system for fire risk on residential properties, and corresponding building requirements that get progressively more stringent with the hazard. Interestingly, the most cost-effective way to comply with their most stringent requirement for windows is multiple-glazed tempered glass.  

This perspective could advance the whole discussion of non-energy benefits in the energy policy community. Myopic cost-benefit analysis often applied to energy-efficiency projects typically ignores benefits such as improved safety.  Accounting for energy savings attributable to disaster-resilient measures would vastly help their economic case.

Of course, disaster resilience and energy efficiency don’t always go hand in hand, and each deserves to be pursued in their own right.  But if we can collectively recognize the rich synergisms it will help advance both of these practices and give us a building stock that is truly more sustainable.

Views: 1518

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Evan Mills on May 15, 2013 at 3:44am

Kevin - J.C.'s recent post brought me back over here, and I see that I never responded to your last note.  Totally agree that there is a big role here for PV and other renewables.  Like your neighborhood-scale vision.  We need grid-intertied PVs to be able to power loads in the home even when grid down.  Hybrid or EV could make a nice "UPS-on-wheels" as well where on-site storage does not otherwise exist....

Was interested in reviewing the link in your first post (below), but it's not working.  Do you happen to have a new URL for that info?

Comment by kevin parcell on August 29, 2011 at 3:03pm
I take your point about the extended benefits of envelope efficiency.  As you note, neighborhood sourcing isn't equivalent to off-grid, and when it's not it contributes to grid resilience.  Neighborhood sourcing also facilitates lowering GHG inasmuch as we end dependence on cheap primary sources to compensate for transmission loss, and so this approach contributes to global sustainability.  In that regard, neighborhood plants can also facilitate energy profligacy without necessarily generating GHG, making our energy gluttony a reality that we can face rather than fight.  I predict (why not) that the next generation of home energy professionals will be focused on sizing neighborhood- and home-energy plants (with envelope efficiency accomplished), applying our metrics expertise to helping reach the net-zero results.
Comment by Evan Mills on August 29, 2011 at 2:38pm

Kevin - Grid independence is certainly a good thing (altho, of course "zero-net" isn't necessarily the same as off-grid).  Every little bit helps.  My point is only that there are certain unique attributes of certain energy-efficiency features that improve disaster-resilience, beyond reduced vulnerability to power outages.

Comment by kevin parcell on August 29, 2011 at 2:25pm

I like your focus on the integrated approach and I agree with your equation, but 2+2 isn't the only way to get to 4.  I personally favor net-zero energy neighborhood/community sourcing as the best path to both resilience and sustainability.  With this alternative approach, efficiency delivers a bonus because it permits the neighborhood plant to serve more customers without enlarging its footprint, but I think that this consideration illustrates that efficiency isn't an absolute requirement for resilience or sustainability.

http://community.acumenfund.org/profiles/blogs/1bpp-10-the-tipping-...

Cheers,

Kevin

Forum Discussions

Why is Air Sealing Important?

Started by Cameron Home Insulation in General Forum 1 hour ago. 0 Replies

Greetings :)

Started by Dennis in General Forum. Last reply by Diane Chojnowski 17 hours ago. 2 Replies

Electro Magnetic Fields (EMF)

Started by Barry L NewDelman in General Forum. Last reply by Brad Cook 17 hours ago. 12 Replies

Zehnder Comfopipe vs. rigid pipe

Started by Alan Lehman in HVAC yesterday. 0 Replies

Follow the action at HPC 2018

Started by Diane Chojnowski in General Forum yesterday. 0 Replies

Latest Activity

Cameron Home Insulation posted a discussion

Why is Air Sealing Important?

Hello guys, Tell me, Why is Air Sealing Important? Share your views.Why is Air Sealing Important?See More
1 hour ago
Ryan T De La Rosa posted a blog post

Home Energy Savings In An Unlikely Place

When thinking of the best way to save mother nature, it's likely that the last thing on your mind…See More
8 hours ago
Taylor Joseph Mckay replied to Taylor Joseph Mckay's discussion Seeking to Purchase Blower Door in the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
"please shoot me an email taylor.joseph.mckay@gmail.com"
11 hours ago
Diane Chojnowski replied to Dennis's discussion Greetings :)
"Welcome Dennis! Great to have you join us! "
17 hours ago
Brad Cook replied to Barry L NewDelman's discussion Electro Magnetic Fields (EMF)
"Whoa! EMFs are everywhere, but they are not all equal. The characteristics of EMFs varies very much…"
17 hours ago
Ben Thompson replied to Taylor Joseph Mckay's discussion Seeking to Purchase Blower Door in the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
"Hi Taylor.  I have a Minneapolis Blower Door set up for sale. DG-700 manometer was factory…"
18 hours ago
Arn McIntyre replied to Taylor Joseph Mckay's discussion Seeking to Purchase Blower Door in the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
"Taylor I have item described below for sale.  Pictures are posted in Equipment for…"
18 hours ago
Taylor Joseph Mckay added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
Thumbnail

Seeking to Purchase Blower Door

Hi, I'm getting into energy audits and am looking to save a few bucks on picking up a used blower…See More
18 hours ago
Taylor Joseph Mckay joined allen p tanner's group
Thumbnail

Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase

Discuss the pros and cons of the equipment you are interested in prior to purchase. Post equipment…See More
18 hours ago
Sandra James replied to Barry L NewDelman's discussion Electro Magnetic Fields (EMF)
"I am quite interested in how EMF can cause health issues.  There is no question that too much…"
19 hours ago
Sandra James replied to Dennis's discussion Greetings :)
"Hello There, I am new as well. Hoping to learn new things through the course of this time on this…"
19 hours ago
Profile IconJames Sabal, Ethan Foley and Katelyn Haas Conrad joined Home Energy Pros Forum
20 hours ago
Alan Lehman posted a discussion

Zehnder Comfopipe vs. rigid pipe

Hello All,I have installed few Zehnder systems and I am not sure if my rep is giving me the info I…See More
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski posted a discussion
yesterday
Brett Little's 2 events were featured
yesterday
Profile IconSandra James, arthur wilson, Nolan and 4 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
yesterday
Landon added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
Thumbnail

BRAND NEW: Fantastic Software for Retrotec

I purchased a new blower door system from retrotec and it came with the fantestic software.…See More
Monday
CEE posted a blog post
Monday
CEE's blog post was featured
Monday
Brett Little posted events
Saturday

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service