Code Conflict Between 2012 IRC and 2012 IECC

It has come to my attention that there may be a building science-based conflict in the language of the 2012 International Residential Code (IRC) and 2012 International Energy Conservation Code (IECC).

The 2012 IECC sets the mandatory blower door tested and certified air infiltration rate at 5 ACH50 in CZ1 & 2 and an even tighter 3 ACH50 in CZ 3 and above. The problem lies in the fact that the new IECC/IRC also allows builders to install natural draft gas appliances in these homes with no safety testing. There is a significant danger that these appliances will not be always be able to create a positive draft up the flue and CO will be drawn into the home. The IRC says that if your home meets the ACH50 standards of the IECC, you must do 62.2 mechanical ventilation, but nothing about CAZ safety or depressurization. The IRC also says that if you have gas appliances in this home, you must comply with the Gas Section of the International Mechanical Code (IMC) and the IMC says something weird: If the house is less than 4 ACH (50 or natural, who knows) you must have combustion makeup air, but again nothing to address CAZ depressurization due to fans.

Now we have climbed through several codes, none of which makes this trail easy to follow, we still don't have the answer we need.  Unless there is language in the IMC or someplace else that I'm not aware of at this time, we have a threat to public life and safety. 

This oversight will allow the construction of homes with a CAZ pressure and CO related defect that is inherently dangerous, potentially even deadly. For almost two decades, building scientists have known that the tighter a home becomes the greater the negative pressure generated by exhaust fan flows including kitchen and bathroom exhaust fans, appliances and duct leakage. This discovery back in 1986 by John Tooley, and Dr. Neil Moyer then working at the Florida Solar Energy Center, was the beginning in many ways of the study of the interactions between airflows, pressures and building tightness. Mr. Tooley coined the term, MAD AIR to describe what had been discovered.  

This research led to an understanding of how house tightness and airflows interacted to create unbalanced pressures and potentially deadly back drafting of combustion appliances. In response to this research, the ability of natural draft appliances to draft properly was investigated and safety limits for depressurization were established by nationally recognized bodies such as the Building Performance Institute. The following combustion appliance zone depressurization limits are incorporated in the standards of the Building Performance Institute: 

CAZ Depressurization Limits

Venting Condition

Limit (Pascals)

Orphan natural draft water heater (including outside chimneys)

-2 - 5

Natural draft boiler or furnace commonly vented with water heater

-3

Individual natural draft boiler or furnace

-5

Mechanically assisted draft boiler or furnace alone, or fan-assisted DHW alone

-15

Exhaust chimney-top draft inducer (fan at chimney top); High-static pressure flame retention head oil burner; and sealed combustion appliances

-50

As you can see, building scientists found that natural draft gas appliances would experience backdrafting of combustion byproducts including CO into the home when placed under a negative pressure of as little as -2 to -5 Pascals (depending on how the flue was constructed) with reference to the outside. When a home is very tight, as is now mandated and test verified by the 2012 codes, even very small exhaust fan flows will exceed these safety limits.  My concern is that it is very easy to exceed these depressurization levels in the very tight homes we are talking about in the 2012 code. Kitchen exhaust fans with flows under 400 CFM don't require make up air. In a home at 3.0 ACH50, the operation of this exhaust fan alone could very easily create depressurization of -10 Pascals and no natural draft gas appliance in the home could draft safely. 

Example:

2,000 square feet x 9' average ceiling height = 18,000 cubic feet of volume

18,000 CF x 3 air changes per hour = 54,000 Cubic feet per hour of air flow to equal 3.0 Air Changes per Hour at 50 Pascals

54,000 CFH / 60 mins. = 900 CFM50

From these calculations, it is clear that an airflow of 900 CFM will yield 3.0 air changes per hour in our 2,000 sf example home. This is the highest CFM and leakiest that a new home can be built under the 2012 code. What pressure will a 300 CFM kitchen exhaust fan generate in a home of 900 CFM50? The following chart taken from the Operation Manual of the Minneapolis Blower Door of The Energy Conservatory graphically depicts the relationship between house tightness, airflow and house depressurization.

The vertical blue line represents the air tightness of the leakiest 2,000 sf home allowed under the 2012 IECC at 900 CFM50. Note that all homes built tighter than this will experience even greater house depressurization than the barely code compliant home as the blue line shifts to the left on the chart. The green box at minus 2.0 Pascals represents the level of depressurization at which a natural draft gas water heater reaches the BPI CAZ depressurization zone safety limit. The fan flow of a  kitchen exhaust fan at 300 CFM will depressurize the home to minus ten Pascals (red arrow/box)! This is twice the safe maximum depressurization allowed for a gas furnace and two to three times what a gas water heater can safely operate against. Simply turning on a clothes dryer or two bathroom exhaust fans to generate an exhaust flow of 200 CFM will result in a depressurization of minus five Pascals (purple arrow/box). You can all fill in your own "worst case depressurization scenarios" here. 

I feel strongly that we the building science community must have a discussion regarding this issue. The sooner the better. What are the solutions that are acceptable to the marketplace? Draft induced and sealed combustion appliances will work, but will all stakeholders be willing to sign on? 

This oversight needs to be addressed before jurisdictions across the country begin to adopt these new codes.

 

- Doug Garrett

Doug Garrett, CEM, is president of Building Performance & Comfort, Inc.  

 

Views: 1367

Comment

You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by John Nicholas on April 14, 2015 at 11:44am

I just noticed this thread is almost two years old.  That may say more than anything.

Comment by John Nicholas on April 14, 2015 at 11:43am

There are some wording issues to be cleared up.  The larger issue is to remember what else was going on at the time these codes were being written.

1.  The new DHW standards that just kicked in were there.

2.  The elimination of all but sealed combustion furnaces in the colder CZs was heading for a start last year. The lawsuit killing that standard had not been filed.

3.  You are assuming that every AHJ has adopted and enforces these various facets.  

Finally,  what is a good professional practice and the legal minimum the AHJ is willing to enforce or the ICC can put down in a consensus standard are probably never going to be the same.

Comment by Richard Scott Mills on June 22, 2013 at 9:26am

This shows the need to bring ERV/HRV into the home building code. Balanced pressure and tempered fresh air should be a no brainer for code writers.

Latest Activity

Henry Borysewicz joined allen p tanner's group
Thumbnail

Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase

Discuss the pros and cons of the equipment you are interested in prior to purchase. Post equipment…See More
yesterday
Henry Borysewicz liked allen p tanner's group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
yesterday
Chris Stratton commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"@ Jonathan 1. Cost of PV array was about $15k before 30% federal tax credit. 2. The financial…"
Friday
Chris Stratton commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"@ Brennan Hey thanks! Yeah, it's time for an update on the energy consumption now that…"
Friday
Chris Stratton commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"@Grey re: estimated vs. actual production Good question! The estimated first-year annual production…"
Friday
Diane Chojnowski's video was featured

People Who Save Energy 1: Builders

Millions of people work to save energy in the United States. They work in every state, across industries and technologies. To show the diverse arc of this growing workforce, we visited North Carolina. This video tells the stories of some of these…
Friday
Jonathan Nadle commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"Hi Jim, Thanks for your well thought-out and written piece.  I agree with your comments on…"
Thursday
Leo Klisch commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"WOW! 913kwh/12= 76kwh/month. How is that possible? I live in central Minnesota and started with…"
Thursday
Leslie Jackson replied to Leslie Jackson's discussion DIY Filter Solution for an Evaporative Cooler, anyone?
"Thanks Rich, I hope they thought of that, but you are on to something. I think I learn more doing…"
Thursday
grey staples commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"Curious to know how the kWh production turned out relative to what the installer indicated you…"
Thursday
Brennan Less commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
"Hey Chris, y'all are kicking butt!! I'm sure your new HVAC won't use any energy,…"
Thursday
Rich Manning replied to Leslie Jackson's discussion DIY Filter Solution for an Evaporative Cooler, anyone?
"Have them call a HVAC contractor and install a filter system"
Thursday
Rich Manning replied to Jerry Needham's discussion Condensation on ceiling and walls of master bedroom
"Looks like a leaking ridge vent"
Thursday
Jonathan Nadle liked Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
Thursday
Matt Peterson posted a blog post

Gas Line Installation In Portland OR Code Basics

When you're looking to undertake any kind of a remodel or repair in your home it's important to…See More
Thursday
Brennan Less liked Jim Gunshinan's blog post Our First Year with Solar Panels, by Chris Stratton
Thursday
Pearl Home Certification posted a blog post

Press Release: HomeSmart International Joins the Pearl Broker Advantage Program

Vienna, Virginia and Scottsdale, Arizona – July 19, 2018 – Pearl Certification and HomeSmart…See More
Thursday
Franco Oyuela commented on Allison A. Bailes III's blog post The Ductopus or the Centipede - Which HVAC Duct System Is Better?
"Many older homes were constructed without air ducts. Ductless systems can provide much needed air…"
Thursday
Franco Oyuela commented on Chris Laumer-Giddens's blog post The Ductless Mini-Split Heat Pump's Big Brother - CITY MULTI
"The compact design and long piping system gives homeowners free reign for designing a ductless…"
Thursday
Terry Hill's event was featured

Passive House Institute US 2018 Conference at Boston

September 19, 2018 at 6pm to September 23, 2018 at 7pm
Annual conferenceSee More
Thursday

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service