Reposted from i.e., the Center for Energy and Environment's Innovation Exchange blog --

Last October, former Apple employees garnered a lot of media attention when they announced that they were designing the Nest: a smart and aesthetically pleasing thermostat. We reviewed their product in May on our blog i.e., and the Home Energy Pros forum recently hosted an interesting discussion about its energy saving potential. 


As an Apple fanboy, I was intrigued. But I wasn’t seeking a $250 replacement for my 20-year-old programmable Chronotherm any time soon. Programmable thermostats are available for a little more than $50: why would any rational person spend four to five times that price for a Nest or other comparable wifi-enabled smart thermostat?

According to the Nest website, the thermostat learns your schedule and automatically programs itself. It senses when you are gone and adjusts the temperature. You can program it from your smartphone or tablet, and it can display your energy history. To do all this, the thermostat has activity sensors to monitor occupancy, a humidity sensor, three temperature sensors, and a wifi connection to enable monitoring of local weather conditions. It uses its wifi connection to upload data to the cloud.  It could be possible to observe a house’s energy history including house air temperature, thermostat set point, and energy use (since it knows when the furnace or AC is on or off); as well as outside weather. 

Wow!  As a building researcher, I hate to estimate the cost of measuring and monitoring this data. But with it you could calculate the time constant of the home, create a house UA value or overall building thermal response factor. And Nest now has people paying $250 to create this data set?! Nest has not released its sales figures, but its units sold are presumably in the tens of thousands, perhaps more. Nest has sold in the mid-hundreds of thousands of units! Wouldn’t it be great to access this data? Imagine a home energy label based on actual energy use and house balance point! We wouldn’t even need to visit the house. (Hmm, maybe for a free $250 thermostat, a homeowner might sign a release form...)

Researchers have found that most homeowners do not use the programmable thermostats correctly and so the installation of programmable thermostats fail to provide their anticipated energy savings. Two of the Nest’s key selling points are its usability and its learning capabilities. Maybe this is the programmable thermostat that will actually achieve its energy savings potential!

Oh, and did I mention that it is really cool? When celebrities like Leonardo DiCaprio drive Priuses, it certainly doesn’t hurt their sales.

The Nest thermostat would not receive the same media coverage if it weren’t being mentioned in the same breath with Steve Jobs and Apple. The connection embues Nest with an aura of innovation and user-friendliness. Their product has a lot of cool energy saving features. A recent update added more and I suspect even more are on the way. And perhaps its $250 price tag is attracting attention and motivating purchases. People are willing, and maybe even expect, to pay a premium price for a brand they trust or covet even when cheaper alternatives are available. 

As consumers, we would like to think that we are rational and objective in our purchases, but often we are much more swayed by emotion than logic. When selling home energy retrofits, our auditors use a rational approach to convince homeowners, our customers, to invest in energy saving products and services. We feel that we are delivering a successful residential energy program because 28% of our homeowners complete our recommended home energy improvements. But we have room to grow. Almost three out of four homeowners who could have work done on their houses -- to reduce their utility bills, improve their comfort, and increase the resale value of their house -- chose not to do so, even with incentives like rebates and low-interest loans. 

Perhaps we could expand and multiply our approaches. We have a lot to learn from the marketing of the Nest thermostat. We need to clearly define the segments of our target audience and understand how to truly engage each segment. We need to create a message that appeals emotionally to our audience. In the case of the Nest, the message is “energy efficiency is cool and fun and we don’t mind paying a little extra for the experience.” Can you guess who their target audience is? My guess is that it’s one of ours as well.

Related CEE program:

Community Energy Services

Related post:

The Nest Thermostat: Saving Energy Can Be Fun

Views: 2140


You need to be a member of Home Energy Pros Forum to add comments!

Join Home Energy Pros Forum

Comment by Lester Shen on August 28, 2012 at 6:27pm

I think AT&T is also looking at providing an energy management system as as GE. One of the highlights reported at the Consumer Electronics Show last January was the number of smart thermostats and energy management systems that were coming on the market. Choice is great. The question is about increasing adoption and utilization, not one method over another. The more the merrier. We should embrace "different strokes for different folks" rather than dismiss them.

Comment by Richard Scott Mills on August 28, 2012 at 2:56pm

You can get the full monty of energy man'gt system from Comcast for $150 with plug controlls for all your A/V and computer systems. The Wiser for $300 can connect your home to your utility w/ a full smart meter system w/out the cost of a smart meter. When Apple brings in a new system it is usually an elegant next gen app. The Nest is not that.

Comment by Abe J Degnan on August 28, 2012 at 8:30am

@Don-- because more government mandates always solves the problem of consumer acceptance? Raising prices helps consumers?

Comment by Lester Shen on August 27, 2012 at 1:56pm

Don, I totally agree about the security system aspect and a lot of players are entering that space (Lowe's and Best Buy, among others.) I imagine utilities might think about it too with smart meters and the ability to control appliances and lighting. Framing it as part of household security and home automation is a natural, esp with smart phone integration. Right now with fuel prices, energy conservation is a hard sell

Comment by Don Ames on August 27, 2012 at 1:40pm

Nice article with additional info about the Nest. I would love to try one, but not ready to fork over the $250. I think the direction we should go to establish energy efficiency in homes is to require Nest technology in new homes and then tie the technology to security. Buy a new home and you get state of the art security and energy conservation. I think people are ready to buy security, but not ready to buy energy conservation.

Latest Activity

Jonathan Beers posted a discussion

MGE hiring for my job

I'm retiring next spring, and MGE is hiring:…See More
2 hours ago
Summer Reyes's blog post was featured

Equipment We Use: Detecting Water With Infrared Cameras

You know water is somewhere on the property, you can smell the mildew, but can't determine the…See More
4 hours ago
Profile IconGlenn Hourahan and Joseph Frasier joined Home Energy Pros Forum
4 hours ago
Alfredo Baccari added a discussion to the group Job Board

HERS or/and BPI Energy Inspector in SF Bay Area (SAN JOSE, CA).

ELEM3NTS is a leading energy efficient consulting company specializing in residential homes. We…See More
5 hours ago
Alfredo Baccari joined Diane Chojnowski's group

Job Board

This group is for posting jobs related to all aspects of the home performance industry including…See More
6 hours ago
David Byrnes's blog post was featured

Strategies for Hiring and Interviewing for Home Performance Professionals

Hire slow and fire fast.  It’s a phrase that experienced managers and human resources professionals…See More
8 hours ago
Dara Bowser replied to Don Fugler's discussion joining ducts in the group HVAC
"Good to hear you have clean dryer ducts Don. The dryer duct issues that we run into are…"
Don Fugler replied to Don Fugler's discussion joining ducts in the group HVAC
"David, If the IMC mandates metal dryer duct and prohibits metal screws, they must be accepting…"


  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2017   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service