Hello Pros.

I have a client for whom I'm about to engage in stage 3 of improving the comfort in his home.

One of my partner contractors is recommending vinyl siding with 3/8" integral insulation.

My question is this: is this approach similar to employing continuous rigid exterior insulation. My guess is no.

He is recommending wrapping the walls then installing this vinyl siding product.

Thanks in advance!

Views: 661

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Pretty much worthless energy wise & while the VSI will try to sell it that way, it isn't - durability & looks wise it is a step up

Yes the walls definitely need to be wrapped before installing this - make sure you get the flashing & rim details right so you don't trap moisture between this product & the WRB (though some do include drainage channels)

Thanks Sean. Coming from you it carries a lot of weight.

Another reason to avoid insulated vinyl siding, besides the middling R value improvement, is that it eliminates the air space behind the vinyl siding.  The air space in vinyl and aluminum siding allows for ventilation drying of moisture that either leaks in through the cladding (via rainfall), or from interior sources (air leakage and diffusion of interior moisture).  This ventilation drying buys you a lot of "forgiveness" and safety in this wall.  This air space also relieves hydrostatic pressure of water in the cavity.  More info in the links below.

BSD-105: Understanding Drainage Planes

http://www.buildingscience.com/documents/digests/bsd-105-understand...

"With vinyl and aluminum siding, the drainage space is more pronounced and furring is not necessary."

BSI-057: Hockey Pucks and Hydrostatic Pressure

http://www.buildingscience.com/documents/insights/bsi-057-hockey-pu...

A workaround if having to use a siding type that traps moisture is simply using furring strips ripped from plywood 1-1/2" wide vertically to vent condensation, this also moves the siding off the sheathing to reduce conductive-radiative losses to cold winds & overheating from direct sun.

Sean is spot on.

I would only add that the best bang from your residing dollar will come as a result of a VERY CAREFUL installation of the WRB, and all the associated components -- taping the seams, carefully sealing around existing windows and doors and penetrations, and caulking at the top and bottom plate lines.

Essentially, try to get your contractor to understand and treat the installation of the WRB as a true Air Barrier.

A study by NJIT with video instruction on how to "Re-Side Tight" can be found here. http://www.buildingmedia.com/ReSideTight/

I wouldn't agree that the energy benefit is worthless.  A study that we did for he Building America Program that looked at insulated vinyl siding in retrofit applications did show energy savings.  The study should be published by Building America soon.  Although limited, the study showed improvements in both air sealing and thermal performance of the wall.  There is no reason an insulated vinyl siding application couldn't be part of a solution for improving the performance of the walls and could be used along with other insulation and air sealing approaches.  

Thank you all for your input. It confirms my suspicions.

I had originally recommended removing the existing vinyl siding, then wrapping the walls with Tyvek, flashing the windows, sealing the window rough openings, and installing a 3/4" layer of continuous polyiso.

I did this with my house (a 1904 bungalow in Arlington, VA), and created a 1/2" drainage plane between the polyiso and Hardie siding. The results have been pretty awesome. I heated my house this winter with (3) space heaters.

My client didn't want to spend the additional money to add the drainage plane due to the significant added costs of building out the windows, etc.

Is it a bad idea to do what I recommended to my client originally without a drainage plane (using standard vinyl siding)? If so, I will simply have to recommend Tyvek and selling the window rough openings only.

Thanks!

If you must eliminate the drainage plane, you might consider using one of the WRB's (make sure it's also an air barrier) that are designed to 'hold out' the siding -- Tyvek Stucco Wrap, or Benjamin Obdyke HydroGap are products that claim to do that.

Great, thanks Craig. I read up on Tyvek's Stucco Wrap many moons ago and completely forgot about it.

If you are using Hardie on a building,   James Hardie recently released a note that says in the near future NEW installations using their product WILL require at least a 3/8 air gap for the drainage plane. If you want their warranty.  

For residential products... 

http://www.jameshardie.com/d2w/best-practices/appendix-glossary-esr...

I haven't been able to find the notice about the gap being required... but it may be possible that I had been looking on the commercial building side.. and that requirement is noted in the opening paragraph of the document liked above.

It's about time! I love Hardie products but I had my reservations in the part when installing them per status quo.

Interesting, in that I had a "heated" discussion at the Seattle Home Show about a week ago with a distributor of a vinyl siding product that had insulation.  While I personally would avoid the product,  he did make a valid point in that they had differentiated their product from the others by using about 1" of foam insulation... in fact it was that profile of the siding that caught my eye and stopped me at the booth.  It was the first time I'd seen a vinyl siding product that thickness of the foam was pretty nearly 1" at all points... instead of thin slice at the top.   

They had also put drainage groves on the back side of the foam... with the intent to reduce traping water and break the capillary effect.

But as noted,  I would not buy the product for any application that I have at the present time.   If you are going to reside the house and want to add insulation - allow for the cost of pulling off the old stuff and inspect the existing sheathing first,  seal it so its air tight,  and then add on something like Comfortboard-IS (rock - wool like product).  and new siding over that... 

RSS

Latest Activity

CEE posted a blog post
3 hours ago
Sean Lintow Sr replied to Chris Bellanca's discussion Overheating garage
"There are only two methods - block the heat before it gets in & exhaust what gets in Blocking -…"
7 hours ago
John White posted photos
14 hours ago
John White posted a blog post
15 hours ago
Rob Madden posted a discussion

E&O Insurance

Any recommendations for a good E&O and general liability insurance carrier for energy…See More
19 hours ago
John Redmond added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
Thumbnail

Flir I7 Infrared Camera (Barely Used)

I have been away from this site for a while, so my apologies if this is supposed to be posted…See More
21 hours ago
John Redmond joined allen p tanner's group
Thumbnail

Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase

Discuss the pros and cons of the equipment you are interested in prior to purchase. Post equipment…See More
21 hours ago
Hannah Wood liked Quinn Korzeniecki's discussion Application Period for 2018 Energy Auditor (EA) and Quality Control Inspector (QCI) Pilots Now Open
23 hours ago
Quinn Korzeniecki posted a discussion

Application Period for 2018 Energy Auditor (EA) and Quality Control Inspector (QCI) Pilots Now Open

We need you!Applications are now being accepted to participate in the 2018 Energy Auditor (EA) and…See More
yesterday
Quinn Korzeniecki added a discussion to the group Building Performance Institute (BPI)
Thumbnail

Application Period for 2018 Energy Auditor (EA) and Quality Control Inspector (QCI) Pilots Now Open

We need you!Applications are now being accepted to participate in the 2018 Energy Auditor (EA) and…See More
yesterday
David Butler replied to Chris Bellanca's discussion Overheating garage
"Easy... insulate the attic ceiling. I'm not sure how much good it would do to air seal a…"
yesterday
Chris Bellanca posted a discussion

Overheating garage

Hi all, I'm looking for potential solutions to a problem at a client's house.  The south facing 2…See More
yesterday
Landon added a discussion to the group Energy Auditing Equipment for Sale, Trade or to Purchase
Thumbnail

Brand new retrotec blower door system $3000

Hi, I’ve got a brand new blower door system from retrotec that I got 2 months ago, and never got…See More
yesterday
John Redmond posted discussions
yesterday
David Holtzclaw replied to David Holtzclaw's discussion GSHP for domestic hot water
"Thanks John & Bill. Bill your experience is one reason why I wanted a larger heat pump with…"
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski posted events
Wednesday
Rob commented on Bob Krell's group Healthy Indoors (IAQ)
"Hello, Has anyone tried custom filtering of window AC units? Specifically concerned with…"
Wednesday
Michael Dunseith's 2 photos were featured
Wednesday
Franco Oyuela commented on Perry Ning's blog post Warnings About Portable Air Conditioners
"Here are the top five benefits of owning a portable air conditioner: 1. Low Price – All…"
Wednesday
Daniel Baur-McGuire commented on Kurt Shafer's status
"Whole house fans are a scam if you use air conditioning. Seriously "
Tuesday

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service