Tankless Water Heaters... has their time finally come?

For decades tankless water heaters haven't been worth the effort to install due to our artificially low cost of natural gas in the USA and the high price of tankless heaters. Tankless water heaters have dropped to under $1,000 while tank water heater prices have continued to climb. Are tankless water heaters worth rethinking?

I have found 3 basic types of tankless water heaters:

1: Non-modulating with battery powered igniter such as they use in Europe. These can be bought in the US for under $230, and use 1/2" gas lines. Most will require an vent upgrade to 4" B-vent. 54 -87% efficiency.
http://www.amazon.com/dp/B009EFVS8A/ref=twister_B00B5EZPUK

2: Modulating tankless that automatically adjusts the burner output based on temp rise and water flow. They sell for about $550 but must either be mounted outdoors or require very expensive Stainless Steel venting. Most require upgrading gas lines to 3/4". 82% efficiency
http://www.supplyhouse.com/Takagi-T-KJR2-IN-NG-T-KJr2-IN-Takagi-Tan...

3: Condensing that can vent with ordinary PVC pipe, cost just under $1,000. Also requires 3/4" gas line and condensate drain. 95% efficiency.
http://www.supplyhouse.com/Takagi-T-H3J-DV-N-T-H3J-DV-N-Indoor-Tank...

Views: 7468

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

So I would not ever presume to be expert in engineering, and would be cautious holding myself out as knowing more about that field that I am NOT more than tangentially involved in because I recognize there is more to it than I can get from staying at a holiday in express.  

I find all types of professionals think EE and Building Science is something they can speak of as authorities.  Architects, home inspectors, HVAC techs, PE's.  

But as an engineer don't you hold your work to a higher standard?   Any time a change is made to a system, don't you have liability if you don't consider the impact of your change on the whole system?  If you don't, then aren't you risking potentially severe unintended consequences that will fall back onto your lap? 

If you don't take a band aid approach in your field, why would you recommend people use it in mine?  We are not talking about changing a light bulb.  

Yes, I do... re-read my comments in the whole blog.  It was pro's and con's, plus the need to consider some of the little things that often get over looked.

 I also recognize that a solution that works well in one region can be a very poor choice in another region.  That may even extend with in the bounds of a city.  Some areas of Seattle have gas, some don't... asking gas company to run line for NG so they can install a tankless would be a silly request.   Using a tankless in a low electric rate region -- when the heater would be run off of propane would be silly.

Step back and look at the whole picture...

And I am more than tangentially involved in EE and building sciences...

Bob's blog was a specific topic - sometimes you need to focus on the merits of the topic and not try to pull the conversation to far adrift.

FWIW the water heater is in a garage closet next to the furnace. The WH's fresh air supply is fed from the unconditioned air in the attic. A tankless heater could go back in the original location or brought indoors. Bringing indoors would offer a 15' shorter water lines to point of use, but may also use indoor air for combustion depending on the model selected. The current location is subject to infrequent below freezing conditions. The gas manifold is also closer to the indoor location, reducing the cost to run the new gas line.

tankless water heaters are a pretty old idea. They originated in Europe as a way to heat water at the point of use. They were mounted in the kitchen near the sink and the water supply was taken off the one cold water supply line, that at that time was made of lead. Later another heater appeared  inside the house (venting into the house) in the one bath room. Again the houses normally had just one water supply line still lead pipe Later one copper line was installed and the wall mounted heaters had a couple of foot of copper pipe from the one supply line.

I haven't seen one installed in Europe since the early 60's.

Its possible thatother regions of the world developed something similar. Anyway it's old obsolete technology.

Steven, last time I was in Germany,  nearly every residential house (older than 10 years) was still using tankless.  Newer houses were moving over to solar hot water.  In the 70's many of the small pension houses had little water heaters that you would turn on and lite before taking a shower or bath.  Those have been replaced with the flash electric hot water heaters.

At least two chain hotels that I've stayed at in Berlin were using in bath flash heaters for showers and the sinks.  It was just easier for them to upgrade the rooms and push for higher efficiency... without the centralized boilers for all the rooms.

One of the units that Bob listed is made in Puerto Rico.  

It really depends on the local energy costs, availability and culture.   I can't imagine anyone in their right mind installing a tankless gas or tankless electric hot water heater in Hawaii.  I would think carefully about it in Arizona, parts of Southern California, Texas, Florida... they have a good solar insolation and the systems do not need the freeze protection. 

China has probably more solar hot water heaters installed than anywhere else in the world... for many it worked better because they don't necessarily have the NG infrastructure - and in some cases the electric infrastructure is also a problem.

But I can also think of cases where it really makes sense.   I have a load heat load house... probably under 30,000BTU.  Forced air.  I could combine an larger Rinnai tankless and their water-to-air AHU to replace my older larger furnace.   (house has(is) undergoing deep retrofit).  Small gas furnaces are hard to find.   I am not fond of the air to air heat pumps for a furnace replacement... 

The point is that there are cases where it might make sense and others where it would be inappropriate.

Hi Dennis,

I last worked in Germany in about 1989 and lots of old houses still had them and they served.. but most new houses (1980's) that I saw and stayed in had high efficiency central gas boliers for house heat and hot water. The boilers could heat justwater for showers etc. in the am or pm and there were an increasing number of  electric mini tankless in the kitchen.

My mother had a mini electric tankless in her bathroom (on the shower wall)because she took showers at odd times of day.

Apart from those mini electric tankless at the point of service I haven't seen a use for the larger tankless in cooler climates. My knowledge of europe is more the UK and Belgium ... I ought to be more specific.

I now live in Mexico and  ... yes I'm 100% solar radiation.

Cheers!!!

That is probably what I was seeing also.  I  spent time in mid seventies, late 80's quick trip, then 2000, and later 2010, 2012.   The pensioners  (B&B) places still seem to use more point of use.  In 2012, I saw a lot of solar hot water in places I didn't think it would make sense.  In the mid/late 90's Russia cut off the NG supply over disputes with the UK and western Europe (sounds a little familar..) so it may be that some of the construction moved back to point of use for some hot water.  I have family and friends that are over across northern and southern Germany... I should ask.

Even if NG is cheap and available in Mexico,  I'd still go for solar h20 first.  They don't seem to have the price premium for the tanks and materials that we have in the US.

A tankless water heater can be a bit pricey. Tankless water heaters can range from $300 to $1100 or more depending upon the model. Gas tankless water heaters are typically a little cheaper. Tankless water heaters are more complicated than traditional models and have more electronics. This results in a corresponding price increase, but the long term energy savings can make up for that difference. 

If you plan to install a gas tankless water heater, you'll also have to factor in the cost for venting to the outside and any needed electrical requirements. If you do not already have an outside vent, this installation can get a little pricey depending upon the length of the vent needed and any cutting that needs to be done.

Another option would be to install a smaller tankless water heater only where you might need the unlimited supply of hot water, such as in a bathroom that has a long run from this water heater.

Those are DIY install prices - not that cost is relevant now. If the goal is to go carbon free, fuel switching minor appliances helps ready homeowners for shifting the major appliance.

We are taking our clients all electric. We feel that if we don't at least show them the path, we are not behaving ethically. 

The presumption of savings opportunity in hot water has been gradually exaggerated to the point it's gone beyond laughable to gross. People seem to be assuming this number rather than measuring it. 

So we've been measuring. 

If people use a LOT of hot water a heat pump water heater may justify, but we are finding the $ cost of electric water heat is less than the savings from the avoided billing charge from getting rid of the gas meter.  

Add to this the fact tankless need more maintenance, often LOTS more, and the hot water "quality" often really sucks (customer experience - delivery time, consistency, etc), means you are doing them unknown/unrecognized amounts of disservice. 

Don't sell gas appliances. Shift your clients to pure electric. That is the path to net zero ready.

With super cheap natural gas prices now, still worth going all electric?  Tankless needs a lot more maintenance  delime each year plus costs of extra power used?

Yeah.

Gas water heaters Suck

http://energysmartohio.com/uncategorized/why-gas-water-heaters-suck...

How many negative's will you suffer to save $5 or $10 a month? Isn't it a bit like spending quarters to mine nickles? 

Gas won't stay cheap. Markets move toward equilibrium eventually. And most can't produce their own gas when it gets expensive.

Electric is the energy most people can produce themselves if the power company gets too pricy, so there is price inelasticity in electricity that doesn't exist in other energy carriers.

RSS

Forum Discussions

Insulation Blower Recommendations?

Started by Jim Conlon in General Forum. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus 1 hour ago. 3 Replies

Best brands for furnace

Started by Jignesh in General Forum. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus 2 hours ago. 2 Replies

Efficiency of furnace

Started by Jignesh in General Forum. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus 2 hours ago. 10 Replies

2005 EPAct tax credit

Started by Mandy Leazenby in General Forum. Last reply by Sean Lintow Sr Feb 15. 3 Replies

Latest Activity

Eric Kjelshus replied to Jim Conlon's discussion Insulation Blower Recommendations?
"Most generator are more efficiency at 240 volt.   Its  about the total watts more…"
1 hour ago
Eric Kjelshus replied to Jignesh's discussion Best brands for furnace
"Its more about the install and air flow than the box brand,  Most brands about the same if you…"
2 hours ago
Eric Kjelshus replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"OK lets say you have a gravity air system with a 80% burn on heat exchanger with out the 8"…"
2 hours ago
John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"System Efficiency is great.  Not much use, if you don't intend to fix the various…"
11 hours ago
John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"Furnaces and all HVAC Equipment is rated by AHRI.  You can get the certification as to the…"
11 hours ago
Jacob Corvidae replied to Diane Chojnowski's discussion Support Mike Rogers in the group News & Announcements
"Hey Mike! We're all routing for you! Don't hesitate to ask for help.  Jacob"
12 hours ago
Jacob Corvidae joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

News & Announcements

Share your news and announcements with the community in this group.To post news or an announcement,…See More
12 hours ago
Diane Chojnowski added a discussion to the group News & Announcements
12 hours ago
Profile IconJeannette Moore, David Carson, Jesse Smith and 3 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
13 hours ago
Home Energy Magazine's blog post was featured

How We Turned Our House into a Giant Foam Box, Part I — Wall Insulation By Wen Lee

Chris Stratton and Wen Lee are a husband-and-wife team living in the Los Angeles area who are DIY…See More
yesterday
Home Energy Magazine posted a blog post

How We Turned Our House into a Giant Foam Box, Part I — Wall Insulation By Wen Lee

Chris Stratton and Wen Lee are a husband-and-wife team living in the Los Angeles area who are DIY…See More
yesterday
Chris Stratton replied to Chris Stratton's discussion Technical question about mini split heat pump line set maximum length
"Hi Chris, Thanks again for your help. Update: the system is now up and running. Chris"
yesterday
Home Performance Coalition's blog post was featured

From Philly to DC: Join Us on Capitol Hill

By now you have probably heard – as part of this year’s …See More
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski added a discussion to the group News & Announcements
Thumbnail

Nominate a visionary leader for the Linda Wigington Leadership Award

The Linda Wigington Leadership Award celebrates visionary leaders doing extraordinary work to…See More
yesterday
Home Performance Coalition liked Chris Morin's blog post HVAC: A Fast Growing Career Opportunity
yesterday
Home Performance Coalition liked Diane Chojnowski's blog post Home Performance Coalition Calls on Congress to Support Federal Energy Efficiency Programs
yesterday
Home Performance Coalition liked Home Energy Magazine's blog post Andrew Scatizzi- Stick to the Basics in New Construction
yesterday
Home Performance Coalition posted blog posts
yesterday
Safe-R Insulation commented on Safe-R Insulation's blog post What are the advantages of Cavity Wall Insulation?
"Hi, Cavity wall insulation are more effective and increase wall life. And it will also help to save…"
yesterday
Profile IconMichael R. Johnson and Jerry Phillips joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Wednesday

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service