Is it worth the cost to retro-fit radiant barrier into existing attic space in southeast part of USA

Roof is 4/12 hip, 2200 sf

Tags: Insulation, Radiant

Views: 276

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

You know the answer is it depends - what are you trying to accomplish, why, how much are you willing to pay for it... Is it shady, do you have a tile roof... http://thehtrc.com/2012/building-science-radiant-barriers 

With that once all air sealing, insulation work etc... is done properly, probably not though it can help with certain issues & might still be worth it. Now if you are redoing your whole roof I see no issues with adding the radiant sheathing though I would probably opt for a cool roof treatment thus negating that

I know we have a few members here that like spray on (i.e. they sell it) & that can honestly help overcome some longtime issues with others and generally is easier to install until you hit baffles & insulation which you would need to redo

In new construction, I used to specify TechShield roof sheathing (OSB with RB already installed), which cost about 10 cents extra per sq.ft. of roof (may no longer be accurate). Then I read a large study of Energy Star homes in Houston included homes with ducts in the attic, sealed to Energy Star standards. As expected, those with radiant barriers cost less to cool than those without RB's, after adjusting for other factors. However, the difference was surprisingly small, on the order of 3% of cooling energy IIRC. In addition to verified duct leakage, one would imagine that these homes had better-than-code air sealing and ceiling insulation, all of which reduces potential savings from the RB. Bottom line: even at only 10 cents extra, radiant barriers were only justified in the hottest climates, such as Houston, Miami, etc.

There's obviously no way to retrofit a radiant barrier for that cost (unless the roof sheathing is being replaced for other reasons). Some argue the Houston study isn't a fair comparison for older homes with leaky and poorly insulated ceilings and attic ducts. However, I would argue that fixing those problems offers more bang for the buck. I've seen retrofit RB quotes for upwards of a dollar or sq.ft !! At that price, I can't imagine it would ever come close to payback.

The HP Forum Archives (see link in main menu bar) has a number of discussions on radiant barriers, including links to the above referenced Houston study, as well as a study by FSEC on retrofit radiant barriers in Florida.

Thanks, David

I had in mind the RB film that attaches to underside of the rafters. 

duct work is located in the crawl space, so other than low head room in attic 4/12 hip, no other obstruction. 

A couple of issues with that - working around the trusses is a pain for that especially to get everything right & it gets to be real tight real quick. The biggest though is dust settling on the sheets over time which has been shown to reduce the effectiveness of the barrier. Plus I second David's thoughts - no ducts no need. Do what I suggested first, fix the air sealing & insulation (which includes baffles) and you have no need 

If no ducts in attic, I can't imagine any rationale for installing RB. If the objective is to reduce ceiling (cooling) loads, fix the ceilings.

It’s hard to choose on of these as most of the time the reviews and buying guides found on the net rarely include a “user critics” section which gives more insight about the product. One of the websites I found interesting and which include this important section is:  https://heaterslab.com/best-radiant-barriers/
 

RSS

Forum Discussions

high rise humidity

Started by Steve Nations in HVAC. Last reply by David Butler yesterday. 4 Replies

Ducted mini split vs ceiling cassettes?

Started by Alan Lehman in General Forum. Last reply by Alan Lehman on Thursday. 5 Replies

70 unit building rehab

Started by Jerry Needham in Multifamily. Last reply by Jacob Corvidae on Thursday. 3 Replies

Indoor Air Quality Monitors and Meters

Started by Rob Madden in General Forum. Last reply by Al Tibbs on Tuesday. 13 Replies

Latest Activity

Profile IconAlida Baker, Heather Schall-Lucas and Kathleen Krebs joined Don Fugler's group
Thumbnail

Kitchen Ventilation

In many homes, cooking is the largest indoor source of air pollutants. Exposures can be higher in…See More
8 hours ago
David Butler replied to Steve Nations's discussion high rise humidity
"Yes, you should be able to measure differences in RH, especially at the supply, as Sean said. But…"
yesterday
Steve Nations replied to Steve Nations's discussion high rise humidity
"Thanks for the replies.  David, do you think I should be able to see any humidity difference…"
yesterday
Alice La Pierre commented on Don Fugler's group Kitchen Ventilation
"I volunteer with a non-profit that provides free home repairs for low income seniors and people…"
yesterday
David Butler replied to Steve Nations's discussion high rise humidity
"@Steve, I concur with Sean's comments. Your client is just throwing money out the window…"
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski posted a discussion

United Way partners with NEST to help low-income households save energy

In our every day lives, it can be easy to overlook the simple pleasures like a warm place to sleep,…See More
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski added a discussion to the group Habitat for Humanity
Thumbnail

United Way partners with NEST to help low-income households save energy

In our every day lives, it can be easy to overlook the simple pleasures like a warm place to sleep,…See More
yesterday
Profile IconTyler Chilcott, Aidan Conway and Todd Kistler joined Home Energy Pros Forum
yesterday

© 2019   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service