I've been doing HP assessments for 12 years, but find myself a little limited in my knowledge of this issue.

Here's the scenario: I do an initial assessment where I find a 7-year old NG water heater with 1500 ppm undiluted CO. The homeowner brings in his plumber to "fix" it. The plumber, who doesn't own a CO monitor, cleans the burner and air intake grill, and proclaims it good. After work is done on the home, I re-test and find the CO to be even higher this time, and the draft weak.

What typically can be done to a fairly new water heater to fix the CO problem? The gas/air ratio must be out of wack, I'm thinking. Is it usually corrected by replacing the gas control valve?

The homeowner is left hanging, the plumber is without a clue and me telling him it needs to be corrected. I would recommend a different plumber, but I want to find out what a knowledgeable individual would typically do to correct this, short of replacing it. One thing I know is I need to align with a knowledgeable person to address this in the future.

John Shillito

Tags: CO, heater, plumber, water

Views: 1045

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I have to agree with Kurt. 2000 ppm is exceedingly high. I have tested hundreds of hot water heater (NG, Oil) and mostly they come in around 16 ppm. There is clearly something wrong and we all know that a gas hot water draft can easily be compromised. 

hey thanks for the links. Very informative on FVIR units

Hello John (and everyone else in the forum),

I'm a new visitor at this forum and it this is my first post. I look forward to more sharing and learning in the future.

The first condition that I would investigate the "weak draft". Is the flame lazy too? Is the equipment in place the same as what the flue was originally designed for?

I find the best place to contact when at a loss is the manufacturer's technical support.


1. Inspect flame .. nice blue is perfect.. white is a sign of carbon monoxide and incomplete combustion..orange too much oxygen but does not mean CO,,  If it consuming entire chamber and larger than normal flames it most likely overfired. could just need to be adjusted or replace valve. 

2,  Inspect burner and inspect primary air is at least open.. May have to be opened more but leave it to a pro.. . also look for debris or some material interfering with burn like a mouse or bird.. if debris is on burner , have it cleaned.. .  (HAVE PRO DO THIS). Make sure burner is seated correctly.. 

3. check for over firing ..clock gas meter.. I think KRIeger's residential Home Energy book has a section on clocking  Gas meters,, . as for auditing this is probably the best least intrusive  test for you.You need a stop watch and a calculator.... You do not  want to break rule  #1.. DON'T GET IN OVER YOUR HEAD!!!!

But out of box this should not happen.. check gas valve and manufacturers plate to make sure its not Propane,, Then you have to install natural gas valve or at least change orifice  (PRO again).. 

You can have a professional plumber test the pressure on the gas valve with a water Manometer or digital Manometer..It should be set 3.5 i.w.c or a little lower.. check manufacture plate for this rating and input BTU;s..  . and there is a adjustment screw to adjust pressure on the gas valve,  but leave that to a licensed service man... If he does not have these basic tools or know how to adjust gas pressure,, FIND A DIFFERENT PLUMBER,,, 


1 can not tell by flame.   New water heaters you look though a small little opening -  you can not see the flame.    We need a flue gas meter to read the O2 and CO  and flue temp.   

2. right on - must look at rust and stuff on burner.  impingement bring up high CO

3. clock gas meter?  have tried this?  what is the BTU of gas?   this can change each min or each hour and each day.   I have seen Nat gas go from 800 BTU per Cub foot to 1050 BTU's  in same hour but not normal.  Must use flue gas meter!   I have seen gas meters off 36% with the "tar" off Nat gas that's why they get rebuild each 10 yr.    When testing try keep each burner the same presser

So CO is a sign of incomplete combustion.  There are lots of things that can cause that. First cause is cold combustion surfaces.  If you put a cold pot on a gas stove top the CO spikes.  You need the burner to be rocking for a few minutes before you test. Also, 1500 is stupid high.  I would bring along either the old school glass tube tester or the CO alarm. 

The next thing that causes CO is insufficient oxygen.  This might be a lack of combustion air (fresh air). That would support the weak draft. The other thing that doesn't help this is doing this test in the peak of summer. Doing a combustion test could show low oxygen (or no oxygen) in the combustion gas.  Cleaning everything should help this. I assume there are no fans or motors, so check the pitch on the venting. 

The other cause of CO is burner issues. Insufficient oxygen can be caused by too much fuel. This is causes by someone messing with the burner or replacing parts. The other burner problems can be caused by rust, spiderwebs, damage, etc. 

The fix for all these things, power vent or direct vent water heater. Unless you find the venting issue or burner issue. 

CO of 1500 Into the Atmosphere is NOTOK any time or anywhere

Replace the water heater ! the Pressure Valve Might be off, the Burner Might need adjustment or might be defective. By the time you fix them you will probably spend as much as a new Water heater. You should also look at the piping connections and the Shut Off Valve and if they are not same age as HWH Replace them.

Caz Testing should reveal the cause of the Weak Draft. Several times I have Non Passing draft Flue #'s on clay lined Masonry Chimneys. It did not pass or barely passed, I told the Homeowner They had to get a Chimney PRO to check it it out to make sure it was clear. More than a dozen times the chimneys were almost completely Blocked !! 

Where I work if you orphan a HWH  (Convert the Furnace to Sealed Combustion) You are required to install a Stainless Steel Liner in the correct size. Also if a HWH is 40,000 BTU or Higher it requires a 4" flue. Max 3 90 Degree Elbows. Make the Flue pipe on top of the heater ( I call it the HWH Chimney) as tall as you can while keeping a 1/4 inch rise to wall Thimble. Max run is 10'.

While the Homeowner is responsible to make the required repairs & it may not be in the scope of the audit, I learned most of the above knowledge in my BPI training class 7 years ago,and I always talk to HVAC pros to gain more knowledge. Whenever I see a problem I will not leave the House until drawing a picture of the problem and what I recommend to correct it. I also offer the phone # of a Professional who I have worked with and make it clear they don't have to use my guy, But they need to fix it promptly.  And I let them know I will not do any work done until the problem is fixed and reinspected.

Hope this helps,


Forgot to add

Make sure you have sufficient Intake air for the room. You should have 1 sq inch per 1000 BTU's of all appliances in the CAZ, Preferably 50%  6" from the ceiling and 50%  6" from the floor.  Remember Louvered Grills have 40+% less clear space than their Dimension size. And it is OK to make the area larger


You can get combustion air from from the supply air from blower.   If blower is on 24/7/365 and seal the return air duct and filter slot.  Make the furnace room postive and add air to combustion.   I have seen to much combustion air grills go the wrong way.   Chimney back drafting are common with unsealed return.    


Forum Discussions

Mini split installation location

Started by Jan Green in HVAC. Last reply by David Butler 15 hours ago. 1 Reply

Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans

Started by Beverly Lerch in General Forum. Last reply by David Butler 18 hours ago. 11 Replies

Tankless water heating and existing gas lines

Started by Julie Saporito in HVAC. Last reply by Kent Browning on Friday. 5 Replies

Whole House Fans - Love 'Em or Not?

Started by Tom Conlon in General Forum. Last reply by John White Sep 10. 77 Replies

Latest Activity

David Byrnes's video was featured

Why One Room Is Hotter Than Others

Ever wonder if your air conditioner is working right because one room never gets a cool or warm as others? Do you need a bigger air conditioner to fix a room...
40 minutes ago
Profile IconEric MacCallum, Adam Morgan and Caolan Hutchens joined Home Energy Pros Forum
14 hours ago
David Butler replied to Jan Green's discussion Mini split installation location
"Really hard to advise without knowing the layout. But you're asking good questions. Any chance…"
15 hours ago
Jan Green posted a discussion

Mini split installation location

Reaching out to the experts today to ask about location of installation of a mini split.  I'm a…See More
16 hours ago
David Butler replied to Beverly Lerch's discussion Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans
"Among the various opinions expressed here, I offer a few 'truths'... Ceiling fans are…"
18 hours ago
Walter Ahlgrim replied to Beverly Lerch's discussion Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans
"This is one of thouse topic where you ask 10 people and get 12 different opinions. I will give you…"
21 hours ago
Brett Little's event was featured

Full Circle Urban Forestry: Introducing Urban Wood Opportunities - Free CE Webinar at Webinar Online

October 17, 2018 from 12pm to 1:15pm
Many common urban tree removal practices in the United States view felled urban trees as costly…See More
22 hours ago
Beverly Lerch replied to Beverly Lerch's discussion Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans
"Now I am confused.  Everyone has a different opinion.  "
22 hours ago
Joseph Novella replied to Beverly Lerch's discussion Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans
"Don't use the fans! They generate heat and mix the stratified high warm air with the low cool…"
22 hours ago
John White replied to Beverly Lerch's discussion Mini split air conditioners and ceiling fans
"If you are using air conditioning, a ceiling fan will allow you to raise the thermostat setting…"
John White posted a blog post
Profile IconDana Launius and Susan Dee Cummins joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Linda Wigington liked Don Fugler's discussion Depressurization/make-up air issues
Profile IconCourteney Hazard, Erin Kelly, Megan Bailey and 3 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Kent Browning replied to Julie Saporito's discussion Tankless water heating and existing gas lines
"First the problems - increased CO due to poor combustion, flue condensation delayed ignition, etc.…"
Brett Little posted an event

Full Circle Urban Forestry: Introducing Urban Wood Opportunities - Free CE Webinar at Webinar Online

October 17, 2018 from 12pm to 1:15pm
Many common urban tree removal practices in the United States view felled urban trees as costly…See More
Hannah Finch's blog post was featured

Announcing National Energy Geek Day [October 6]

If you know anything about EnergyLogic, you are probably aware that we are fun loving and…See More
John White commented on Corbett Lunsford's video

5 Types of Ventilation for Controlling Your HOMEChem

"Ventilation is one of the single most important element of an HVAC system. It is generally used to…"
Profile IconDevin Cecere, John Cooper, Beth Burrell and 1 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Brett Little commented on Jim Gunshinan's blog post More "Buzz" from ACEEE Summer Study—Builder-Installed Electric Loads
"Ive got one of those stupid street lights! When I bought the house I was like how do you shut…"


  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service