I'd like to know if BPI has banned the use of the duct blaster in the presence of asbestos ductwork. Is this the case? If there is any documentation from BPI, what/where is it?

Views: 716

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I don't know about BPI, but I discussed this issue (blower door and asbestos, same thing) years back with my insurance carrier and we agreed, any, that is any, asbestos and they want to see documentation from a licensed abatement company (who has insurance) stating that it is either safe as is or has been cleaned up properly and is now safe.  Since I'm not trained and licensed by the state, that is not a decision I can make.

I can't see any way BPI can state it is ok to proceed as there are many variables and again, we are not normally trained, licensed, and certified (or insured) to make that determination.

Finding asbestos in a house is an issue that I discuss in advance with the home owners so they are not blind sided by my departure.

Bud

In all seriousness - just how many do you see (tested to make sure it was) & do you really think running the tester would be worse than them running the unit normally?

With that - BPI states in EP / Heat & not sure which other ones:

Where the presence of asbestos, lead, mold and/or other known or suspected hazardous material is present, all relevant state and federal (EPA) guidelines must be followed to ensure technician and occupant safety. Blower door depressurization tests may not be performed in homes where there is a risk of asbestos becoming airborne and being drawn into the dwelling.

So no they don't ban it (and do we really need someone telling us putting our hand on a hot stove isn't smart) nor do they ban pressurizing a house

I rarely test asbestos- I just perform a visual on-site.

I do not think running the duct blaster would be worse than running the system itself. For this reason, in particularly bad cases, I have recommended not running the system at all until further investigation or an abatement is performed.

I think discussing it with the customer prior to a site visit is a great idea because different customers have different attitudes to asbestos for valid reasons.

There are customer-based, safety-related, financial and legal reasons not to run the duct blaster with asbestos, especially if it looks friable. And, as in the hot stove analogy, nothing good can come from running the duct blaster with asbestos, except for a more accurate rebate estimation. However, for this reason alone, the end does not justify the means.

Two states have concluded that blower door testing does not increase the liability wrt asbestos.  As some of you have suggested, life as usual disturbs it more than testing would. I doubt most blower door or duct testers have the time or skills to find it, so not looking is not such a bad idea because that is kinda what happens. 

Those States by the way, wanted assurance they would not be creating problems prior to instituting a blower door program. 

We find asbestos duct tape pretty commonly in our area of NW Washington State (and in some cases, fully wrapped duct runs). Our program has a policy of not conducting the blower door test when vermiculite is present in attics or friable asbestos tape is present on ductwork. Until recently, we had left it up to the auditor to evaluate whether they were comfortable completing the blower door or not, but as some of these comments have pointed out, we're not certified or insured to make this call. 

Having said all of that, I'll also give my personal opinion. When vermiculite is present, I don't test. This material is typically not disturbed and is well separated from the living space until we turn on a blower door (even pressurizing stirs it up, and fibers can remain in the air for days and days). When asbestos tape is in good condition (no tears of frayed edges) and limited only to seams in metal ductwork and boot-to-floor connections, I agree the blower door test couldn't possibly cause any more disturbance than the air handler typically does.

I would like to test in the latter scenario described above, but my opinion goes against our official policy, which means we are limited to estimating leakage in many cases. Fortunately, though, we also do a very thorough visual inspection which guides our workscopes as much as the numbers do. Without impressive numbers to show the homeowner paying for the work, they have to trust the other information we provide.

Asbestos in ductwork is often on the outside of the ducts and is commonly asbestos duct tape and mastic (the mastic may also contain asbestos), but it is on the exterior of the ducts in the attic or crawlspace or basement and not in the living area. Sure some mastic may have gotten squeezed into the cracks and seams, it is unlikely to be a source of friable asbestos - so why does everyone stop duct testing when it is on the outside?

Vermiculite should be tested for asbestos content before walking away from a job. Not all vermiculite contains asbestos.

I have run into and away from powered, blown-in asbestos insulation in attics (in a county that paved their roads with asbestos containing rock that had to be removed for all roadway surfaces after that was discovered). Scary. After informing the residents as to the nature of their insulation most didn't care and wanted their attics blown with additional insulation anyway.

Do no harm, right? Testing the material before walking doesn't harm, and who knows you might not have a problem.

As HERS Raters in California we cannot run tests if it is present per CEC protocols. It is a slippery slope here in the litigious Republic of California. I would error toward caution and if you suspect there is asbestos to not test, have suspected materials tested and recommend abatement if present. Whether or not it is in BPI HERS or other protocols is really not important. Protecting you and your clients is.

RSS

Latest Activity

Sean Lintow Sr replied to John Carton's discussion Insulation touches underside of roof in home with no soffit or soffit venting.
"Location, location, location In hot dry climates - not really an issue unless it gets damp (and yes…"
3 hours ago
Michael Schettine liked Michael Schettine's video
3 hours ago
Bradford E. White replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Agreed! True, if an open plan. Simple is best. But away spaces seem to be making a come-back. And…"
5 hours ago
Kurt Shafer replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Jerry, as an energy consultant I imagine you are well versed in solar systems. Have you seen how…"
5 hours ago
Scott Mills replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"I have found that ceiling fans are the simplest way to control room stratification "
6 hours ago
Matt Peiris replied to H.O. Electric's discussion Stop Drinking Bottled Water! in the group News & Announcements
"Well water consumers need to test their water every year. Elevated arsenic, nitrate levels or…"
7 hours ago
Kurt Shafer replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Jerry I don't have videos posted yet but I have some nice pictures from customers. See them…"
7 hours ago
Scott Mills is now a member of Home Energy Pros Forum
7 hours ago
Bradford E. White replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Qualified "It Depends" kind of answer. 1. Temperature Perception: There is an intangible…"
7 hours ago
John Carton posted a discussion

Insulation touches underside of roof in home with no soffit or soffit venting.

I performed an assessment for a recent home buyer and the home inspector they hired when they…See More
8 hours ago
Jerry Needham replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Kurt Thanks for the information on the whole house fan and the advise about leaving the fan on all…"
8 hours ago
James White replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"There is more than fan energy to be saved by setting fans to run on "auto". Most forced…"
8 hours ago
Kurt Shafer replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Jerry, I am a whole house fan expert but not an HVAC expert. However, I have no idea why any HVAC…"
8 hours ago
Jerry Needham replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Ken This is a great response.  Lots of arguments against leaving the fan on. THANKS"
8 hours ago
Luke Langhals replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"If an E/HRV system is installed in unison with the furnace ducting -- you might consider making the…"
8 hours ago
Ken Summers replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"At Comfort Institute we get asked this question all the time.  The argument for leaving the…"
8 hours ago
Allison A. Bailes III replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Jerry, as Chris Heenan said below, running the fan continuously will raise the indoor humidity in…"
8 hours ago
Chris Heenan replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"In regions with _high_ humidity, running the fan continuously will be put moisture that the…"
8 hours ago
Barbara Smith replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"Eliminating continuous furnace fan operation is #3 on list of top ways to cut energy use, in this…"
8 hours ago
tedkidd replied to Jerry Needham's discussion HVAC Question about running fan continuously Vs. setting on Auto so it runs when AC or Furnace runs
"There is no Pat answer. It depends. In a well performing home with proplerly sized equipment and…"
9 hours ago

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service