How much does cycling losses of a gas furnace reduce AFUE vs. Thermal Efficiency? Loss of efficiency for oversized AC units is well documented, but I haven't been able to find anything conclusive on gas furnaces.

Views: 526

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

I have the same question as well.

I was looking at displacing my oil heat with a mini-split/ductless heat pump. The payback seamed good until I calculated in my cycling losses or idle loss and domestic hot water generation. My 53 year old boiler with 20+ year old burner running at 80% efficiency consumes almost 300 gallons of oil annually for cycling & DHW. At 486 gallons of oil used a year, the lowest I can reduce my oil consumption is by an additional 186 gallons without replacing or abandoning my boiler.

What can I use to compare cycling losses between boilers? I need something with more information than an AFUE rating.

Energy Kinetics has some marketing information on cycling losses, which is great to help sell their System 2000 products. I would like hard information, not sponsored by one manufacturer.

If I can save 30% on the cycling losses by updating my boiler I can reduce my consumption by 100 Gallons annually. That’s without savings from an 80% efficiency burn to an 90+ AFUE burn. Talking with a neighbor who changed his boiler to a System 2000 boiler four years ago, he noted he has seen an average of 58% oil reduction. If I had the same results I would use only 204 gallons of oil a year!

Perhaps some of the companies who provide both oil and HAVC service have some solid usage numbers that can be referenced to show boiler upgrade saving.

ENERGY STAR's web site has a savings calculator for Furnaces:

http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?fuseaction=find_a_product.showP...

and a similar one for boilers.  Presumably these calculators would estimate *actual* savings in the field available from installing a new furnace "box" (with new AFUE) while the rest of the system, ducts, etc., remained the same.  Which is the usual case.  Perhaps this would shed light on your question. 

Also, DOE is setting a minimum electrical efficiency standard for furnace fans (where there isn't one now).  The furnace fan definitely impacts the total energy use of a home's furnace/heating system, especially since the same fan is often used for non-heating air circulation, and cooling circulation as well.  Comments will be taken until Dec. 24.

http://www.regulations.gov/#!documentDetail;D=EERE-2010-BT-STD-0011...

How efficient of a furnace are you starting with...

My guess is others will say the comfort issues are (temp swings) are more of an issue with an oversized furnace.

Hi Joshua.

AFUE's are a great thing to compare things when all conditions are the same and known.

Your boiler with integrated hot water is not covered in AFUE numbers. Here is a link to a report

by an Alaska outfit that tried to make sense out of AFUE's:

http://cchrc.org/docs/reports/afue_final.pdf 

In the report is a reference to work done by a researcher by the name of Butler who is 

doing work on boilers with integrated hot water at Brookhaven Lab.

You can analyze things a great deal, or you can look at your neighbor's example and see how much similar your homes and systems are, and take his data into consideration.

A 50 year old boiler might have really large air passages with less heat transfer, the passages might not be clean, (soot is a very good insulator). Considering the ages of the equipment you quote I personally doubt that your AFUE is 80%.

I see 50 year old boilers on occasion and their builders plates sometimes rate their input/output capacity at well under 60%.

Kind Regards

Jan Gravemaker

Seattle

RSS

Forum Discussions

How would you insulate this roof?

Started by David Butler in General Forum. Last reply by David Butler 10 hours ago. 2 Replies

Dirty solar panels

Started by Evan Mills in General Forum. Last reply by Stacie Bagnasco 16 hours ago. 1 Reply

Fixing a water heater?

Started by John Shillito in Best Practices. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus on Friday. 21 Replies

Latest Activity

Alfie Davis posted a blog post
Sep 19
Profile IconSam Compton, Cameron Home Insulation, Seth Shoneman and 2 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
Sep 18
Home Energy Magazine's blog post was featured
Sep 18
Eric Kjelshus replied to Gregory Cisco's discussion Abandoning under-slab HVAC ductwork which fills with groundwater seasonally.
"In Kansas City a lot of "cardboard" for supply was used in slab on grade.  1950-1970…"
Sep 15
Richard L. Rue replied to Sonja Persram's discussion Energy Savings Guarantee for single family dwellings in cold climate??
"Try EnergyWise Structures (www.energywisestructures.com) They are a NASA spin-off company that has…"
Sep 15
Debra Little commented on Home Energy Magazine's blog post NREL Research Finds That 22% of New Homes Completed in the U.S. in 2016 Were HERS Rated
"The avg scores are interesting. Are there comparative numbers for previous years? I thought they…"
Sep 15
Home Energy Magazine posted a blog post
Sep 15
Robert Zockoff replied to Gregory Cisco's discussion Abandoning under-slab HVAC ductwork which fills with groundwater seasonally.
"Public water systems regularly "reline" the interior of existing 50 year old water mains…"
Sep 15

Photos

Loading…
  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2017   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service