http://greendreamgroup.libsyn.com/this-house-sucks-but-not-very-har...

Check out this interview with brilliant scientist Brett Singer (seriously, he's a genius) from Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory on our misconception about worst case CAZ Depressurization testing.

Tags: bpi, brett, case, caz, podcast, singer, testing, worst

Views: 1406

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Hi Corbett,

An interesting topic and one where I think I disagree with Mr Singer, but being hard of hearing I'm not able catch enough of his discussion to be specific.  If a text version is or becomes available please post.  IMO, CAZ is very important, to the point where it should be handled by a separate entity trained and certified in all aspects.  When an energy auditor or hvac contractor comes onto a job site, they should have in hand the results and recommendations of a proper CAZ evaluation.  Far too many responsibilities are being placed upon a simple energy auditor for which the training and experience is insufficient.

I do thank you for the post and look forward to some comments.

Bud

I was interested in his contention that backdrafting caused by exhaust fans is going to be diluted by the makeup air being pulled into the house. But wouldn't part of that "makeup" air be the actual gas that's getting pulled back down the flue?

So, on a related note, when a house is really good and tight, where do we assume makeup air for exhaust fans is coming from? Is there ever a time when the exhaust fans don't work because of the tightness of the house?

on a related note,

Exhaust fans flow into a duct that offers 25 Pa of resistance say.  If the house depressurized to -25 Pa as a result of the exhaust fan running the flow would drop by say 50% but would never stop.  Even a Passiv Haus requires 100 CFM to get to 50 Pa; meaning the tightest possible house would not stop the exhaust fan from working at all. But then that house wouldn't/ couldn't have any naturally vented appliances. 

Okay, thanks.  Good to know.

It's about time that somebody challenged all this worst-case depressurization test hysteria. Mr. Singer does a great job of explaining why these first-generation protocols are too crude and need to be updated. This podcast is definitely worth a listen, but I also found a PowerPoint that begins to illustrate some of these same ideas.

Improving the alignment between home performance testing protocols and actual safety risks will help boost the perceived value proposition for these services. That's an upside we all have to look forward to. I just hope it doesn't take us too long to get there.

Thanks for posting this Corbett.

So glad you enjoyed the show, Tom!

Brett brings up a number of very good points about the limitations of current CAZ testing, but there are a few points that warrant further discussion. 

When considering the byproducts of natural gas combustion, we need to consider the impurities in the supply.  In my region (the Front Range of Colorado) our natural gas contains lots of stuff besides methane.  The presence of these other chemicals (mostly other hydrocarbons) leads to a variety of combustion complications that in turn result in a variety of chemicals in the exhaust gases.  Further complicating matters, these impurities vary over time and are not easy to quantify at the consumer level.  The overall result is that complete combustion of all the hydrocarbons is exceptionally rare. 

Brett states early in the interview that the focus of combustion safety is the prevent people from dying from Carbon Monoxide poisoning.  While this is certainly the top goal, it is (as he points out) fairly rare and almost always the result of several problems all happening at the same time.  That said, low levels of CO are being implicated in a wide variety of non-lethal health problems ranging from suppressed immune systems, fatigue, migraines, and a number of auto-immune related ailments such as asthma.  These more diffuse effects are hard to study so it may be a while before we know with clarity where safe thresholds can be found, but there is clearly cause for concern. 

Brett also puts a lot of emphasis on the overall dilution of these indoor air pollutants as a reason to not worry about occasional spillage.  In my experience, this dilution takes place over time, and there is often opportunity for localized exposure that is much more intense.  Usually I have seen this issue in basements with a bedroom located near a mechanical room, or a family room dominated by video game playing kids.  The overall exposure level in the house may seem fine, but there is an unhealthy level of exposure happening anyway. 

This is a very important topic and I applaud Brett bringing up some of the limitations about current testing methods.  Our industry is getting quite good at building tight homes, and we need to pay close attention to how our combustion appliances integrate into these homes. 

- Ron

I'd like to make 2 quick points.

First, we need to stop talking as if only 'tight' houses might have issues with CO and other by-products of incomplete combustion.  We need to remember that 'leaky' houses are not safe houses where these issues are concerned.  In a tight house we can have control over ventilation in a leaky house we are at the whim of nature.  I'd be very interested to know what the ACH was of the homes where we know the cause of death was CO poisoning.  None of the CO deaths I've read about sounded like homes that had been air sealed.

Second, to answer a question raised in the podcast, code does allow natural, atmospherically vented combustion appliances that are in confined spaces to be connected to an interior unconfined space such as the main body of a house.  Not a good idea but it is allowed by code:

All air from indoors, with 1 Upper vent and 1 Lower vent Venting to another interior room/ space

2 indoor vents: When volume of a room/space containing an appliance is too small, an Upper and a Lower vent may be installed into adjacent space with sufficient volume.
Each vent must provide 1 sq. in. NFVA per 1,000 Btuh input, with a minimum size of 100 sq. in. [NFVA = 100 + # of KBtuh above 100]

We need to remember that 'leaky' houses are not safe houses where these issues are concerned. 

Here here.  "The house is leaky so the risk is low" is a perspective that needs nipping in the bud.  

Do you know where the dominant leakage is?  Did the roofer prescriptively add a ridge vent to that leaky house, causing the basement to be more negative under common or uncommon conditions?  Does use of the fireplace cause that water heater to fail (Not so uncommon problem after installing ridge vents...)?  

We need to get rid of natural draft appliances, but that's not going to happen today or tomorrow.  So in the meantime we need to have SOME idea how those appliances perform as installed. 

Frankly, I believe it's unconscionable that atmospheric appliances are still allowed by Code. When we moved into our current (100-year-old) house the VERY first change I made was to replace the atmospheric water heater with a power-vent unit.

Half a dozen or eight years ago, our office put together a white paper and tried to convince our state Code officials to outlaw atmospheric water heaters. 

The builders all said, "TOO EXPENSIVE! Consumers can't afford that expensive water heater."

Forget the hazard reduction -- We pointed out that the house would get back the two square feet of floor area being used to contain the flue AND save the cost of framing and drywalling the chase. (No one builds houses in Wisconsin with an 80% furnace, so the chase usually only holds a water heater flue.) They'd pay for 10 feet of PVC instead of 20 feet of flue. They'd have one less penetration through the ceiling and the roof. Our best guess was that most builders would be able to save more in construction cost than the added cost of the power vent water heater. And they'd cut down the space heating load, due to the reduced air infiltration.

None of it seemed to matter. Just reinforced my conclusion that "built to Code" translates to "the worst house I can get away with."

I'm glad to see that folks are getting interested in this. Ron, great point about chronic low-level exposures. These are certainly of concern, and are on the radar of folks at LBNL. Also, Judy, GREAT point about localized exposure in basement play areas; I had not thought of that, despite having played in one for hours-on-end as a youngster. I think the main point/issue is that while there may be some very rare instances of real problems with CAZ, our current time-consuming, expensive protocols are not very good at identifying them. As for occasional spillage and other CO leakage moments, the cooking with unvented gas appliances in the kitchen almost without question contributes more to overall exposure.      

As home energy experts we had better take this report seriously. We should not be making recommendation for new equipment based on the inaccuracies that it seems BPI wants to continue to support.

I for one want to see just how fast BPI reacts to this and when they will change the protocol. I can hear it now BPI is going to “state we only recommend we don’t mandate”. Well if there is no science to support the position then what is the position based on. We in the industry need to encourage BPI to review their protocols and action tables accordingly before we are accused of being fear mongers praying on a families concern for their children health and safty.

RSS

Forum Discussions

Efficiency of furnace

Started by Jignesh in General Forum. Last reply by John Nicholas 6 hours ago. 13 Replies

Insulation Blower Recommendations?

Started by Jim Conlon in General Forum. Last reply by Brad Cook yesterday. 5 Replies

Best brands for furnace

Started by Jignesh in General Forum. Last reply by Eric Kjelshus yesterday. 2 Replies

2005 EPAct tax credit

Started by Mandy Leazenby in General Forum. Last reply by Sean Lintow Sr Feb 15. 3 Replies

Latest Activity

John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"Any of the various energy modeling programs would give you a starting place. Model the ducts in…"
6 hours ago
John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"That is why gravity systems are much less popular then 50 years ago.   It could easily be…"
6 hours ago
Jim Baerg replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"This is a great discussion.  I'd like to ask a question about the distribution…"
8 hours ago
Michael R. Johnson posted a status
"Diane, Thank you for the welcome, I appreciate it. I look forward to contributing to the conversation. Michael"
10 hours ago
Gary Hall is now a member of Home Energy Pros Forum
16 hours ago
Brad Cook replied to Jim Conlon's discussion Insulation Blower Recommendations?
"Most rental machines will not put out the minimum required pressure for dense-packing. There are…"
yesterday
Brad Cook replied to Jim Conlon's discussion Insulation Blower Recommendations?
"We have been using the Intec Force II for almost 10 years. It only takes about 1 1/2 bags at a…"
yesterday
Eric Kjelshus replied to Jim Conlon's discussion Insulation Blower Recommendations?
"Most generator are more efficiency at 240 volt.   Its  about the total watts more…"
yesterday
Eric Kjelshus replied to Jignesh's discussion Best brands for furnace
"Its more about the install and air flow than the box brand,  Most brands about the same if you…"
yesterday
Eric Kjelshus replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"OK lets say you have a gravity air system with a 80% burn on heat exchanger with out the 8"…"
yesterday
John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"System Efficiency is great.  Not much use, if you don't intend to fix the various…"
yesterday
John Nicholas replied to Jignesh's discussion Efficiency of furnace
"Furnaces and all HVAC Equipment is rated by AHRI.  You can get the certification as to the…"
yesterday
Jacob Corvidae replied to Diane Chojnowski's discussion Support Mike Rogers in the group News & Announcements
"Hey Mike! We're all routing for you! Don't hesitate to ask for help.  Jacob"
yesterday
Jacob Corvidae joined Diane Chojnowski's group
Thumbnail

News & Announcements

Share your news and announcements with the community in this group.To post news or an announcement,…See More
yesterday
Diane Chojnowski added a discussion to the group News & Announcements
yesterday
Profile IconJeannette Moore, David Carson, Jesse Smith and 3 more joined Home Energy Pros Forum
yesterday
Home Energy Magazine's blog post was featured

How We Turned Our House into a Giant Foam Box, Part I — Wall Insulation By Wen Lee

Chris Stratton and Wen Lee are a husband-and-wife team living in the Los Angeles area who are DIY…See More
Wednesday
Home Energy Magazine posted a blog post

How We Turned Our House into a Giant Foam Box, Part I — Wall Insulation By Wen Lee

Chris Stratton and Wen Lee are a husband-and-wife team living in the Los Angeles area who are DIY…See More
Wednesday
Chris Stratton replied to Chris Stratton's discussion Technical question about mini split heat pump line set maximum length
"Hi Chris, Thanks again for your help. Update: the system is now up and running. Chris"
Wednesday
Home Performance Coalition's blog post was featured

From Philly to DC: Join Us on Capitol Hill

By now you have probably heard – as part of this year’s …See More
Wednesday

Photos

  • Add Photos
  • View All

© 2018   Created by Home Performance Coalition (HPC)   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service